PAPER www.rsc.org/pps | Photochemical & Photobiological Sciences
Templating photodimerization of stilbazoles with water-soluble calixarenes†‡
Raja Kaliappan, Lakshmi S. Kaanumalle, Arunkumar Natarajan and V. Ramamurthy*
Received 10th May 2006, Accepted 2nd August 2006
First published as an Advance Article on the web 15th August 2006
DOI: 10.1039/b606658e
Water soluble six and eight membered calixarenes template the dimerization of trans-stilbazoles. In the
absence of calixarenes at the concentrations employed stilbazoles mainly isomerize to the coresponding
cis isomers. Calixarenes help to localize the olefins and orient them in a specific geometry to yield
anti-head–tail dimers. Electrostatic interaction between the sulfonate anion and the pyridinium ion of
the olefin and hydrophobic interaction between the olefin and the host cavity arebelieved to be
responsible for the observed selectivity.
1
H NMR spectra provide evidence for complexation but do not
suggest the exact structure of the host–guest complex.
Introduction
Olefins upon excitation undergo a variety of reactions of which
addition of an excited olefin to another in the ground state has
been extensively investigated both in the solid state
1
and solution.
2
Despite such a long history controlling the regioselectivity during
photocycloaddition continues to be a challenging task. Early
work on this topic pursued by Gerhard Schmidt and co-workers
resulted in the formulation of topochemical rules for solid state
photodimerization reactions.
3–5
However, in the absence of a
thorough understanding of the crystal engineering principles, con-
trolling the regioselectivity during solid state photodimerizations
remains a difficult problem. Following their extensive studies on
the photocycloaddition of enones to olefins de Mayo and co-
workers approached this problem from the solution chemistry
perspective.
6–8
They were able to achieve modest control on the
process using a micellar medium. The molecules were aligned at
the interface between the hydrophobic interior and hydrophilic
exterior of a micelle. Similar attempts by Whitten and co-
workers to obtain selective dimers from stilbazoles in conventional
micellar media were not successful.
9
Based on their observations
in micellar media with stilbazoles they concluded that “merely
orienting chromophores at a hydrophilic–hydrophobic interface
are insufficient to force bimolecular interactions”.
9
In contrast
to normal micelles, when Whitten and co-workers employed a
reverse micelle with much smaller size as the reaction medium syn
HH dimer was obtained from stilbazole.
10
Whitten et al. speculate
that the well ordered and more constrained water pool in reverse
micelles is able to provide better orientation than conventional
micelles. The above results of de Mayo and Whitten’s groups
suggest that the hydrophobic–hydrophilic interface could be used
to orient molecules but the reaction space must be more rigid
and less dynamic than a conventional micelle. During the last
decade approaches based on the principles of supramolecular
chemistry, i.e., controlling chemistry through weak interactions
Department of Chemistry, University of Miami, Coral Gables, FL, 33124,
USA. E-mail: murthy1@miami.edu
† This paper was published as part of the special issue in honour of the
late Professor George S. Hammond.
‡Dedicated to the memory of Professor G. S. Hammond, a pioneer in
photochemistry, a great teacher and an outstanding individual.
(e.g., hydrogen bonding, electrostatic interactions, etc.), have
been pursued both in solution and solid state with moderate
success.
11–23
The above studies led to the understanding of the
basic features needed to control the photodimerization process:
the two olefins must be pre-aligned within a reactive distance
and they should possess very little freedom during their excited
state lifetime. Continuing our interest in ‘controlling chemistry
through confinement in aqueous medium’ we have explored
the use of organic hosts to control regioselectivity during the
photodimerization of olefins. We present below our results with
water-soluble calixarenes as templating nano reaction vessels
(Scheme 1). In this study stilbazoles, whose photochemistry has
been investigated in solution,
24–29
are employed as models to
explore the use of calixarenes as reaction vessels (Scheme 2). As
presented in the next section water-soluble calixarenes were able
to template stilbazoles to yield selectively anti-head–tail (anti-HT)
dimers and permit photoreactions to be conducted in water.
30
Scheme 1
Scheme 2
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry and Owner Societies 2006 Photochem. Photobiol. Sci., 2006, 5, 925–930 | 925