Twenty-first Century Clientelism? State and Community on the Isle of Rum, Scotland Nicola Thompson* and Jane Atterton Abstract This article utilises the concept of the clientelist countryside to examine the similarities and differences between areas dominated by private estates and areas dominated by large public land holdings. While the paternalistic countryside has been widely studied in England, there has been little in-depth work on the clientelist countryside. Drawing on empirical work on the Isle of Rum, located off the west coast of Scotland, the article argues that there are important differences between paternalistic and clientelist country- side typologies. Rum has a population of 31 and is wholly owned by the statutory nature conservation agency, Scottish Natural Heritage. The article illustrates how this public status structures a whole set of social and economic relations between those who live and work there and those who have a professional involvement on Rum. State ownership has created a situation where those who live on the island are divided by their differing conceptions of their professional, community and individual responsibilities. The article concludes by highlighting four key points of differentiation between the paternalistic and clientelist countryside. Introduction I n Constructing the countryside Marsden et al. (1993) argued that rurality has too frequently been constructed as a homogenous entity. They argued for a more nuanced conception of rural space in which the differentiated nature of the country- side was better articulated. Hence, contemporary researchers should focus on the ‘complex assemblage of economic, social and political elements’ which ‘will give individual rural areas quite different complexions’ (Marsden et al. 1993, pp. 185–186). Four categories, or types, of countryside designed to ‘encapsulate major tendencies’ were identified in order to understand the major points of differentiation. The four types were: the contested countryside (where traditional agricultural and development interests are increasingly coming into conflict with incomer populations attracted by the high-quality residential environments), the preserved countryside (dominated by © 2010 The Authors. Sociologia Ruralis © 2010 European Society for Rural Sociology. Published by Blackwell Publishing, 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK Sociologia Ruralis, Vol 50, Number 4, October 2010 DOI: 10.1111/j.1467-9523.2010.00509.x