September 2015 163
OBJECTIVE: CANS (complaints of arm, neck, and/or shoul-
der not caused by a systemic disease or acute trauma) are a rec-
ognized problem in specific occupational groups such as musi-
cians. This study aimed to compare the prevalence,
characteristics, and consequences of CANS between music
academy students and a control group of peer-age medical stu-
dents. METHODS: A cross-sectional study among music acad-
emy students and medical students. Data were collected using
a web-based questionnaire on musculoskeletal conditions of
the upper extremity in the two cohorts. RESULTS: Students
of three music academies (n=345) and one medical university
(n=2,870) received the questionnaire, of which 25% (n=87)
and 18% (n=503) responded, respectively. The 12-month
prevalence of CANS was nearly twice as high among music
academy students as the control group (80.7% vs 41.5%,
p<0.001). Music academy students reported 2.6 times the point
prevalence as medical students (47.0% vs 18.2%, p<0.001).
Chronic CANS was present in 36.1% of the music students,
compared to 10.3% of the medical students (p<0.001). Music
academy students presented more complaints per anatomic
localization and a higher number of involved anatomic local-
izations. Music students rated the influence of CANS on daily
functioning as more severe (5.0 vs 3.1, p<0.001). Of all sub-
jects with CANS during the last year, more music academy stu-
dents (46.3%) visited a healthcare professional compared to
medical students (29.8%, p=0.013). CONCLUSION: The
prevalence of CANS is high in music academy students com-
pared to medical students. This emphasizes the necessity of
effective (preventive) interventions in these high-demanding
professionals. Med Probl Perform Art 2015; 30(3):163–168.
M
usculoskeletal problems among musicians are
frequent, with reported 12-month prevalence
among music academy students and profes-
sional musicians ranging from 39 to 90%,
1–8
while these
numbers vary between 2 and 60% in the general working
population.
9,10
These prevalence estimates are often
focused on the occurrence of musculoskeletal complaints
in the whole body.
2–5,11
However, playing an instrument
mainly involves overuse at the upper extremity and neck
area. The latter is in accordance with studies showing a
high prevalence of musculoskeletal complaints among
musicians at the upper extremities, neck, and mouth.
11,12
Since some studies showed that nearly half of professional
musicians discontinued practicing their instrument at
home during 1 year due to musculoskeletal complaints,
evaluation is necessary.
2
The extent of upper extremity musculoskeletal com-
plaints can be described within the CANS (Complaints of
Arm, Neck, and/or Shoulder) model.
13
In the CANS
model, complaints due to systemic disease or acute trauma
are excluded. This model was developed to support and
compare scientific research and to increase multidiscipli-
nary cooperation, using a delphi consensus strategy. One
of the advantages of using this model is the possibility of
comparing different populations. Systematically describ-
ing the scope of CANS experienced by musicians is not
only an important step in recognizing the extent of the
problem in that specific group in comparison to other pro-
fessions, but it will also give clues for addressing preven-
tive interventions. Thus, the primary aim of this study was
to evaluate the prevalence of CANS among music acad-
emy students compared to a control group of medical stu-
dents; secondly, the impact of CANS symptoms experi-
enced by music academy students compared to medical
students was evaluated.
METHODS
Study Design
A cross-sectional study on musculoskeletal conditions of
the upper extremity in music academy students was per-
formed. A group of medical school students was considered
as a control group. Data were collected from a web-based
questionnaire among 3,215 students of three music acade-
mies and 2,870 students at one medical university in the
Netherlands, extensively described in a previous article.
11
Data were collected between February and May 2011. All
Dutch-speaking students of three music academies
(n=345)—the Royal Conservatoire, The Hague;
CODARTS University for the Arts, Rotterdam; the Ams-
terdam School of the Arts, Amsterdam, with a classical
instrument as main subject (singers and conductors were
excluded)—received an invitation, as did medical students
(studying to be physicians) from Leiden University
Prevalence and Consequences of Arm, Neck, and/or
Shoulder Complaints Among Music Academy Students
A Comparative Study
Laura M. Kok, MA, MD, Rob G.H.H. Nelissen, MD, PhD, and Bionka M.A. Huisstede, PhD, PT
From the Department of Orthopedics (LMK, RGHHN, BMAH), Leiden
University Medical Center, Leiden, and Department of Rehabilitation,
Nursing Science, and Sports (BMAH), University Medical Center
Utrecht, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
The authors declare no funding or conflicts of interest.
Address correspondence to: Dr. Laura M. Kok, Department of Orthope-
dics, Leiden University Medical Center, Postzone J11R, Postbus 9600,
2300 RC Leiden, The Netherlands. Tel +31-(0)71-5263606, fax +31-
(0)71-5266743. laura.m.kok@gmail. com.
© 2015 Science & Medicine. www.sciandmed.com/mppa.
https://doi.org/10.21091/mppa.2015.3031