The International IJSLL ( PRINT ) ISSN -
IJSLL ( ONLINE) ISSN -
Review
Journal of
Affiliation
Department of English and Communication, City University of Hong Kong
email: enbhatia@cityu.edu.hk
IJSLL VOL . – 4 doi : 10.1558/ijsll.v19i1.131
© , EQUINOX PUBLISHING
The International
Journal of
Speech,
Language
and the Law
Storied Conflict Talk: Narrative Construction
in Mediation
Katherine A. Stewart and Madeline M. Maxwell (2010)
John Benjamins 137 pp
Reviewed by Vijay K. Bhatia
Analysis of mediation discourse is a relatively new area of study. In this context,
Storied Confict Talk by Stewart and Maxwell is quite a novel and innovative
e fort. It makes use of fve carefully chosen disputes mediated by the local uni-
versity confict resolution centre, focusing primarily on dispute narratives to
highlight some of the communicative practices of disputants as well as those of
the mediators – especially the way parties in confict talk co-construct their
discursive strategies. As the authors point out, the main purpose of the book is
twofold: frstly, to see the extent to which the mediation cases examined ‘exhibit
features of the bilateral adversarial narrative pattern’ (p. 5) as suggested in
existing literature in narrative theory, and secondly, if not so in all cases, what
‘alternative dispute narrative patterns are co-constructed’ (p. 5) within them.
Although the study has a rather limited scope in terms of the context in which
the confict talk takes place – the data is drawn entirely from the university
mediation centre – the study is quite extensive in terms of its analytic scope and
treatment, and the book, on the whole, is an interesting and insightful explora-
tion of communicative practices in the negotiation of mediation disputes.
Storied Confict Talk is relatively short and is packed with interesting