Nonphotochemical Laser-Induced Nucleation in Levitated
Supersaturated Aqueous Potassium Chloride Microdroplets
Ke Fang, Stephen Arnold, and Bruce A. Garetz*
Department of Chemical & Biomolecular Engineering, NYU Polytechnic School of Engineering, New York University, Brooklyn,
New York 11201, United States
ABSTRACT: We have observed nonphotochemical laser-induced nucleation (NPLIN) in
levitated 8 pL microdroplets of supersaturated aqueous potassium chloride irradiated with
nanosecond pulses of 532 nm light. A much higher supersaturation ratio S of 1.20 was
required to observe NPLIN in a microdroplet, compared to the value of 1.06 for bulk
solutions, attributed to a 40-million-fold lower nucleation rate in a microdroplet at S = 1.06 as
a result of its much smaller volume. This finding has application to high spatial and temporal
resolution pump-probe studies of nucleation in a containerless environment.
■
INTRODUCTION
Nucleation from solution, the first step in crystallization, is a
rare, stochastic, symmetry-breaking event that is difficult to
study experimentally and to model theoretically, and that is still
incompletely understood.
1
It is an essential tool for purification
and control of crystal structure in the pharmaceutical industry,
2
and it is the first step in biomineralization, a process essential
for many living organisms.
3
Not only must solute molecules
cluster to form a separate phase, they also must organize to
form an ordered crystalline structure, and there is evidence that
these two steps can occur sequentially.
4,5
In 1996, our group reported that intense near-infrared
nanosecond laser pulses could induce a supersaturated aqueous
urea solution to nucleate, which we attributed to the optical
Kerr effect, in which the optical electric field induces the
alignment of solute molecules in a liquid-like cluster, helping
the molecules to organize into a critical nucleus. Although
photochemical light-induced nucleation had been known since
the 19th century work of Tyndall,
6
we ruled that out because
the peak light intensities and the near-infrared photon energies
were too low to induce photochemistry, and we called the
phenomenon “nonphotochemical laser-induced nucleation”
(NPLIN).
7
In 2002, we reported that, by simply switching
the polarization state of the light between linear and circular,
we could induce aqueous glycine to nucleate into different
polymorphs.
8,9
Such control over crystal structure had
previously been possible only with chemical additives or
modifying the physical conditions. Since these initial reports,
NPLIN has been observed in a wide variety of materials,
including supersaturated solutions of aqueous L-histidine,
10
hen
egg white lysozyme,
11
potassium chloride and bromide
12,13
and
carbon dioxide,
14
as well as supercooled melts of sodium
chlorate,
15
glacial acetic acid,
16
and the liquid crystal 5CB.
17
Simulations by Peters and co-workers suggest that optical Kerr
interaction energies are too small to account for NPLIN.
18
While several alternative mechanisms have been proposed to
explain some of these observations, including isotropic
electronic polarization
12
and nanocavitation,
14
no single
mechanism appears to fit all of the materials in which
NPLIN has been observed.
Because spontaneous nucleation is a random process, an
experimenter has little control over when or where a nucleation
event will occur. We noted in ref 7 that NPLIN had the
potential to allow an experimenter to control precisely the time
and place that nucleation occurs.
7
In 2009, Alexander and co-
workers demonstrated macroscopic 3D spatial control of
potassium chloride (KCl) nucleation in agarose gels using
NPLIN.
19
In this paper, we report a realization of this goal on
the microscopic scale: the observation of NPLIN in 8 pL
levitated supersaturated solution microdroplets of KCl in water.
Alexander and co-workers have characterized NPLIN in bulk
aqueous solutions of KCl.
12,13
They proposed that the
interaction of the optical electric field with the isotropic
electronic polarizability of subcritical solute clusters decreases
their free energy, making some of them become supercritical.
This system exhibits a relatively low laser intensity threshold
(5.6 MW/cm
2
) at a wavelength of 532 nm and with a minimum
supersaturation ratio S of 1.06. (S = c/c
sat
, where c is the
concentration of a given solution and c
sat
is the concentration of
a saturated solution.) We chose to study KCl because of its low
intensity threshold.
Received: March 27, 2014
Published: April 2, 2014
Article
pubs.acs.org/crystal
© 2014 American Chemical Society 2685 dx.doi.org/10.1021/cg5004319 | Cryst. Growth Des. 2014, 14, 2685-2688