The concept of spatial quality and its challenges on exercised
affordable housing design typology in Dar es Salaam e Tanzania
Buberwa M. Tibesigwa
*
, Long Hao, Benson V. Karumuna
Faculty of Architecture and Urban Planning, Chongqing University, 400045, Shapingba District, Chongqing, China
article info
Article history:
Received 12 March 2016
Received in revised form
1 August 2016
Accepted 17 November 2016
Keywords:
Affordable housing
Design typology
Spatial quality
Design quality indicators
Quality characteristics
Dar es Salaam
abstract
This study explores the influence of affordable housing design typologies on the spatial quality of the
exercised schemes in Dar es Salaam City. Through a questionnaire survey, the study uses a systematic
stratified sampling method to obtain 185 (26.8%) respondents out of 690 households from three spatially
diverse affordable housing schemes. Two-factor without replication analysis of variance (ANOVA) and
descriptive statistics were adopted to analyze the data. Based on eight (8) quality indicators, the findings
revealed 66.5% and 33.5% of the respondents were moderately and above average satisfied respectively
with their overall housing spatial quality, but had low satisfaction about certain aspects. This shows that
the housing spatial quality varies among the three housing schemes. To validate the direct link and
significance level, the ANOVA Test P-value is 0.004175 and 7.88E-05 for columns and rows respectively
(significant at 0.05), which indicates that housing design typologies significantly influences post-
occupancy housing satisfaction in 3 estates. This assessment provides the feedback to design/produc-
tion process on the relationship between housing satisfaction and housing quality attributes. The study
highlights the justification for variables to be considered for appropriate affordable housing design
approach to improve spatial quality for dwellers' well-being in future projects.
© 2016 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
1. Introduction
Tanzania government through public housing agencies has
focused into delivering affordable housing units to house the low
and medium income earners since 1962 (Nnkya, 2014). But this
program faces the challenges of both indoor and outdoor spatial
quality that prolong to undermine desirable housing development
programs in the country (Lupala, 2002). The house need doesn't
limit itself to the accessibility of a structurally stable unit to live in
but must be located and designed to afford amenity, convenience,
health as well as accessing community social life (Kurian &
Thampuran, 2011). In its policy to deliver adequate shelter to all
citizens government has instituted various programs to address the
problems resulting from urbanization trends and increase in pop-
ulation (URT, 2000; Komu, 2011)). Soon after independence
(1960's), Tanzania established the National Housing Corporation
(NHC) to oversee and administer housing development in the
country (Komu, 2011). Early program of eradication of all slums that
had existed in strategic locations of the city and replaced them with
multi-storey blocks of flats that were made of industrial materials
(Ibid), reveals the existence of high quality housing concept in
government policy since after independence. But the government
withdrew from direct housing financing due to financial limitations
leading to public agencies relying on rents to manage available
units while the own built houses by individuals emerging around
the city leading to poor quality housing (Mushumbusi, 2011). In the
established affordable housing program, some of residents are
adjusting their units to fulfill their needs or sometimes to maximize
and improve the units to suit their family sizes (Komu, 2011). This is
an experience that for a long time has been the concentration of
several acknowledged literature pointing towards the policy
stakeholders on changing the delivery approach to satisfactory
quality affordable housing direction (Diang & Hayangah, 2011 , pp.
1e20).
It is argued that, a good planning is complemented by a good
design for a good quality affordable housing product, where the low
design quality leads to dwellers' dissatisfaction, defects in housing
units and un-programmed maintenance (Afaq et al., 2015). Spatial
quality concept is developed from the general concept of space
(Frank, Jan, & Barbara, 2011). The quality of space has different
* Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: btibesigwaezra@hotmail.com (B.M. Tibesigwa), longhao@cqu.
edu.cn (L. Hao), karumunabenson@gmail.com (B.V. Karumuna).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Habitat International
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/habitatint
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.habitatint.2016.11.010
0197-3975/© 2016 Published by Elsevier Ltd.
Habitat International 59 (2017) 44e59