© 2007 Plant Management Network.
Accepted for publication 7 October 2006. Published 22 January 2007.
Effect of a Mustard Green Manure on Potato
Yield and Disease Incidence in a Rainfed
Environment
Peter Sexton, Andrew Plant, and Steven B. Johnson, PO Box
727, University of Maine Cooperative Extension, Presque Isle 04769;
and John Jemison, Jr., 495 College Avenue, University of Maine
Cooperative Extension, Orono 04469
Corresponding author: Peter Sexton. psexton@umext.maine.edu
Sexton, P., Plant, A., Johnson, S. B., and Jemison, J., Jr. 2007. Effect of a mustard green
manure on potato yield and disease incidence in a rainfed environment. Online. Crop
Management doi:10.1094/CM-2007-0122-02-RS.
Abstract
The goal of this work was to evaluate the short-term effects of a mustard green
manure on potato yield and disease incidence for potatoes grown in a rainfed
cropping system. Diseases of interest were black scurf ( Rhizoctonia solani ),
powdery scab ( Spongospora subterranea), and white mold ( Sclerotinia
sclerotiorum ). On-farm trials with large (60-ft wide) replicated plots were
established at three sites in 2003 and 2004, in Maine. Mustard ( Sinapis alba and
Brassica juncea blend) was sown at a seed rate of 10 lb/acre, mowed at late
flowering, and then disked into the soil. In the following season, tuber yield was
measured at each site and compared to that of potatoes grown in barley
( Hordeum vulgare) check plots. Incidence of white mold on leaves and stems,
and Rhizoctonia incidence on tubers, were evaluated at one site over two years.
On average across all the sites, total tuber yield was 8% greater following
mustard green manure versus barley. Mustard green manure was associated with
decreased incidence of Rhizoctonia on tubers, and increased incidence of white
mold on leaves and stems, in the following potato crop. No effect was observed
on incidence of powdery scab.
Introduction
The goal of this work was to evaluate the short-term effects of a mustard
green manure on tuber yield and disease incidence of potatoes in a rainfed
cropping system. In the Columbia Basin of Washington and Oregon, where
potatoes are grown under irrigation with very high yield potential, green manure
mustard has provided similar tuber yields as compared to fumigation with
metam sodium (2,7).
The putative mode of action for suppression of some soil pathogens
following a Brassica sp. green manure is the release of compounds from
glucosinolates which occurs when tissue is macerated (10). In response to
wounding, glucosinolates are hydrolyzed by the enzyme myrosinase releasing a
range of breakdown products. The nature of the breakdown products depends
on the type of side chain the parent molecule possessed. Volatiles released from
b reakdown of glucosinolates have shown a range of activity against various
species of nematodes, insects, weeds, bacteria, and fungi (e.g., 1,3,8,9,11).
However, other studies have failed to show a strong response in the levels of soil
pests to use of Brassica soil amendments or cover crops (2,13). It should be
noted that there is large genotypic variation among Brassica species and
cultivars in the amount and kinds of glucosinolates present (up to five fold range
in glucosinolate concentration) (6). Also pathogens differ in their susceptibility
to glucosinolate breakdown products (11,12).
In the northeastern US, potatoes are predominantly grown under rainfed
conditions with moderate yield potential. In this region, Rhizoctonia, white
mold, and powdery scab are several diseases of concern to potato growers.
Previous work suggests that Brassica cover crops may have some efficacy against
22 January 2007 Crop Management