Copyright © by the Association of American Medical Colleges. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Academic Medicine, Vol. 97, No. 12 / December 2022 1780
Innovation Report
Please see the end of this article for information
about the authors.
Correspondence should be addressed to Sylvia Botros-
Brey, Long School of Medicine, 7703 Floyd Curl Dr.,
MC 7845, San Antonio, TX 78229; telephone: (773)
484-8981; email: botrosbrey@uthscsa.edu.
Acad Med. 2022;97:1780–1785.
First published online June 1, 2022
doi: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000004759
Copyright © 2022 by the Association of American
Medical Colleges
Supplemental digital content for this article is
available at http://links.lww.com/ACADMED/B283,
http://links.lww.com/ACADMED/B284, and http://
links.lww.com/ACADMED/B285.
Addressing Peer-to-Peer Resident Mistreatment
Through the Use of Forum Theatre: A Pilot Intervention
Sylvia Botros-Brey, MD, MSCI, Adriana Dyurich, PhD, LPC, Alixandria Pfeiffer, DO,
Roberto Prestigiacomo, MFA, Hanzhang Wang, MD, MPH, Sarah M. Page-Ramsey, MD,
Joseph W. Basler, MD, PhD, and Ruth Berggren, MD, MACP
Abstract
Problem
Residents may experience mistreatment
by faculty, peers, nurses, or patients.
While faculty are reportedly the primary
contributors to mistreatment, residents
can also be offenders, which merits study.
Forum theatre (FT) is an experiential
learning modality requiring a peer group to
develop problem-solving strategies. FT was
piloted to address mistreatment among
residents. The objective was to determine
whether FT was feasible, acceptable
to resident learners, and could lead to
self-reported changes in perceptions or
behaviors, providing program directors a
focused option to address professionalism
as a competency.
Approach
This initiative was conducted from
September 2019 through February
2021 in obstetrics–gynecology and
urology residencies at UT Health San
Antonio and consisted of 3 phases: a
focus group to identify mistreatment
experienced by residents, resident
volunteers to create and act out the
FT scenario, and enactment of the FT
scenario during didactic time. Residents
completed anonymous retrospective
pre- and postsurveys, as well as at 6–8
months after, to assess knowledge,
attitudes, and self-reported and
observed behaviors. Wilcoxon rank-
sum tests and 2-sample t tests for
proportions were used to compare
variables between groups.
Outcomes
The FT was completed successfully in
both departments during didactic time.
Twenty-six residents participated, 24
(92%) responded. Most respondents
(23, 96%) would recommend FT to
colleagues for teaching professionalism.
Behavior changes were reported by 15
(63%) participants after the program.
After 6–8 months, self-reported
mistreatment behaviors had decreased,
including “making fun of others”
(15 (63%) to 10 (38%), P = .04) and
sending “disparaging texts” (13 (54%)
to 7 (27%), P =.02).
Next Steps
The use of FT during regularly scheduled
didactic times was feasible and
well received among residents. The
evaluation demonstrated sustained
self-reported behavior changes. Plans
are ongoing to expand this approach to
other medical specialties and professions
institutionally.
Problem
Mistreatment in medical education
remains ongoing and challenging. Te
Association of American Medical Colleges
defnes mistreatment as intentional or
unintentional behavior showing disrespect
for the dignity of others that unreasonably
interferes with the learning process.
1
Reports consistently demonstrate that
residents experience mistreatment from
multiple sources.
2
While faculty are
reportedly primary contributors to resident
mistreatment, residents are ofenders up to
28% of the time.
2–4
Residents can choose
to propagate or mitigate mistreatment; fast
pace of clinical duties, extensive training
expectations, and minimal time for
guided refection may pose challenges for
intentional behavior change.
Furthermore, mistreatment topics are not
easily addressed during residency although
they are part of Accreditation Council for
Graduate Medical Education (ACGME)
competencies.
5
Most programs rely on
faculty role modeling for professionalism
training, which is ofen confounded by a
hidden curriculum, wherein mistreatment
results directly from observed faculty
behaviors.
6
Witnessed unprofessional faculty
behavior has been identifed as the greatest
challenge to teaching professionalism;
lack of mentorship, debriefng, or guided
refection further contributes to suboptimal
professionalism outcomes.
5
To our knowledge, few studies have
addressed resident mistreatment while
considering resident contributions.
7
Fewer
still evaluate interventions to interrupt
mistreatment propagation.
7
Forum theatre
(FT) is an experiential learning modality
based on Boal’s “Teatre of the Oppressed,”
which requires peer groups to develop
problem-solving strategies.
8
FT catalyzes
change using guided refection to address
complex professionalism challenges based
on realistic confict scenarios. Learners
become participating spect-actors who
watch, respond, and step into the play,
exploring potential solutions. Troughout,
a facilitator debriefs with participants
and solidifes key messages. FT combines
experiential and observational learning with
refective practice and peer group consensus
building. FT has been used in medical
schools to address racism, professionalism,
and cultural humility topics.
9
Our literature
search did not identify studies using this
modality within residency programs.
We piloted FT at UT Health San
Antonio to evaluate if its use to address
mistreatment among residents was feasible,
acceptable to resident learners, and could
lead to self-reported changes in perceptions
or behaviors, thereby ofering program
Downloaded from http://journals.lww.com/academicmedicine by BhDMf5ePHKav1zEoum1tQfN4a+kJLhEZgbsIHo4X
Mi0hCywCX1AWnYQp/IlQrHD3i3D0OdRyi7TvSFl4Cf3VC4/OAVpDDa8K2+Ya6H515kE= on 01/15/2024