Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Accident Analysis and Prevention
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/aap
Structural equations modelling of drivers' speed selection using
environmental, driver, and risk factors
Reut Sadia
⁎
, Shlomo Bekhor, Abishai Polus
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Technion – Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 32000, Israel
ARTICLE INFO
Key words:
Driving behaviour
Speed selection
Structural equations
Driving simulator
ABSTRACT
Drivers’ speed has significant implications on road users’ safety in general, and particularly so if a crash occurs.
This paper explores the influence of environmental and road characteristics, situational factors, and individual
characteristics on drivers’ observed speed selection in a simulator experiment. The paper presents a theoretical
framework for drivers’ speed selection, and applies structural equation modeling for the various factors ex-
amined. The simulator experiments collected data of 111 drivers driving in 4 different scenarios composed of 22
segments for each scenario. The dataset was analyzed in several resolutions: Driver level, Trip level, and Segment
level. The three models revealed that gender, age, and driving frequency are all significant in determining
drivers’ perceptions and attitudes, which in turn influence speed selection. Situational factors such as traffic
speed, enforcement, and time-saving-benefits are also related to speed selection, as well as infrastructure
characteristics. These findings demonstrate that structural equations provide a flexible modeling tool able to
concurrently analyze the variety of factors that relate to speed selection. As a result, Structural Equations
Modeling provides more accurate and refined explanations for the combined effects of various factors on drivers’
speed selection than previous research so far. These tools can be useful in developing speed management
strategies to improve road safety.
1. Introduction
The long-time research interest in drivers’ speed has risen mainly
from the effect of driving speed on road safety - the faster the speed,
the harsher the resulting impact in case of a crash (Aarts and van
Schagen, 2006). Speed dispersion and variations were also found in
some studies to be related to crash risk (Aarts and van Schagen, 2006;
Sadia et al., 2016). Thus, a great interest remains in understanding how
drivers select their speeds, and how those speeds can be managed. A
wide variety of factors has been studied in relations to drivers’ speed
selection, which can be generally divided into three categories: (i)
Environmental Characteristics - such as infrastructure and traffic
conditions, (ii) Driver Characteristics - such as personality traits and
subjective perceptions, and (iii) Situational factors, defined here as
Additional Risk/Benefit - such as being late to work or spotting a
police car. All of these influence the driver’s individually selected
speed, which may change during a specific trip as a result of changes in
these factors.
Research on Environmental Characteristics related to speed was
mostly collected from aggregate on-road observations, field studies, and
simulated driving conditions such as driving simulators and virtual
reality (De Waard et al., 1997; Fildes et al., 1987; Polus et al., 2000;
Stamatiadis et al., 2009; Tarko, 2009; Van der Horst and de Ridder,
2007). Design consistency studies also reveal how variations in road
infrastructure relate to selection of operating speeds and crash risk
(Mattar-Habib et al., 2008). Specific Environmental Characteristics that
relate to infrastructure and influence selected speeds include horizontal
curves and cross-section elements - such as road, lane, and shoulder
width, the presence of a median, and barrier type (De Waard et al.,
1997; Gitelman et al., 2014; Polus et al., 2000; Stamatiadis et al., 2009;
Tarko, 2009; Van der Horst and de Ridder, 2007). Road-side elements
and road classification also influence speed selection (De Waard et al.,
1997; Fildes et al., 1987; Tarko, 2009; Van der Horst and de Ridder,
2007). In addition, Traffic characteristics may also be perceived as
environmental characteristics related to speed selection; it was found
that in free flow conditions, some driver explain exceeding the speed
limit as an adaption to the speed of other surrounding vehicles (SWOV,
2012). Posted speed limits are assumed also to influence drivers’ speed
selection, but their interpretation varies greatly between drivers
(Mannering, 2009).
Research on driver characteristics was conducted mostly by using
questionnaires and interviews, especially research involving latent
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2017.08.034
Received 4 February 2017; Received in revised form 8 July 2017; Accepted 24 August 2017
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: reut.sadia@gmail.com (R. Sadia), sbekhor@technion.ac.il (S. Bekhor), polus@technion.ac.il (A. Polus).
Accident Analysis and Prevention 116 (2018) 21–29
Available online 20 September 2017
0001-4575/ © 2017 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T