© 2009 Surgeon 7; 4: 198-202 198 | the royal colleges of surgeons of edinburgh and ireland
AMYAND’S HERNIA:
10 YEARS’ EXPERIENCE
1
Division of Visceral and
Transplantation Surgery
2
Division of Cardiovascular
Surgery
University Hospital of
Geneva, Geneva,
Switzerland
Correspondence to:
Ihsan Inan, Division of
Visceral Surgery,
Department of Surgery,
University Hospital of
Geneva, 24, Micheli-
Du-Crest, 1211 Geneva 14
Switzerland
Tel: +41227892101
Fax: +41227892102
Email:
ihsan.inan@hcuge.ch
I. Inan
1
P. O. Myers
1,2
M. E. Hagen
1
M. Gonzalez
1
P. Morel
1
Background: Amyand’s hernia is an atypical groin hernia which contains the vermiform appendix. The
aim of this study was to review a single institution’s experience in the clinical presentation, management
and prognostic factors of this rare hernia. Methods: The authors reviewed records of all patients
undergoing hernia surgery from 1996 to 2006 at their institution, a tertiary care, University-afliated
hospital. Results: Twelve patients (six men) with a median age of 88 years (range 60-97) were included.
Six presented with right inguinal hernias and six presented with right femoral hernias. All required
emergency surgery: eight for strangulated hernias, two for hernias with lower quadrant peritonism and
two for incarcerated hernia. Despite small differences in outcome and length of hospitalisation between
Amyand types, appendix inammation, pre-operative blood examinations and hernia localisation, only
right lower quadrant peritonism as a presenting sign (p=0.004) and age greater than 90 years old
(p=0.04) were signicantly associated with a poor outcome. Conclusion: Amyand’s hernia is a rare hernia
which is seldom diagnosed before operation. It must be considered in the evaluation of a strangulated
or incarcerated hernia. Further studies are required to dene the optimal surgical strategy, prognostic
factors and risks of hernia recurrence.
keywords: appendix, acute appendicitis, hernia, adult, Amyand
Surgeon, 1 August 2009, pp. 198-202
original article
Introduction
Amyand’s hernia is an atypical hernia, diagnosed by
finding the vermiform appendix in a groin hernia,
usually presenting as a strangulated or incarcerated
hernia. It is a rare disease, named after Claudius
Amyand, founder of London’s St George’s Hospital
and first to perform an appendectomy in 1735, for
an acute appendicitis inside an inguinal hernia.
1
Fernando et al. categorised Amyand’s hernia accord-
ing to the degree of appendix inflammation within
a groin hernia: (a) non-inflamed, (b) inflamed or (c)
perforated appendix.
2
Furthermore, some authors
propose that an Amyand’s hernia located at the
femoral canal should be specifically called De
Garengeot hernia, after the Parisian surgeon René
Jacques Croissant de Garengeot, who first described
this hernia in 1743.
3,4
Although Amyand’s hernia is known to most
well-read surgeons, data on this rare hernia are
scarce and mostly limited to case reports, with the
exception of a recent review and three retrospec-
tive analyses.
5-9
Knowledge of this rare disease is
essential to allow pre-operative diagnosis, as well as
rapid and adequate management. Te aim of this
study was to review a single institution’s experience
over ten years, including clinical presentation and
management of Amyand’s hernia, and attempt to
reach conclusions on prognostic factors and risks
of recurrence.
Methods
Patient search strategy and enrolment
Te authors retrospectively reviewed records of
patients undergoing surgery for hernia from 1996
to 2006 at their institution, selecting those in which
an Amyand’s hernia was described. It was defined
as presence of the vermiform appendix within a
groin hernia sac and was classified into three types,
as described previously.
2
Te following parameters were collected and
analysed: age, sex, chief complaint, history and clin-
ical manifestations, white blood count (WBC) and
C-reactive protein (CRP) level at admission, diag-
nostic imaging, type of surgery and outcome. Femo-
ral and inguinal hernias were compared. Duration
of symptoms, WBC and CRP were compared with
the type of Amyand’s hernia found at operation.
WBC higher than 11x10
9
/L and CRP higher than
10mg/L were categorised as elevated.
Te primary endpoint was 30-day hospital
mortality. Secondary endpoints were post-operative
surgical wound infection, hospital length of stay
and hernia recurrence after discharge.
Statistical analysis
Te collected data were analysed using SPSS
statistical software (SPSS 13 for Mac, SPSS Inc.,
Chicago, IL). Kolmogorov-Smirnov and Shapiro-
Wilk normality tests each showed a non-normal
distribution of the collected continuous data; non-