International Journal of Engineering and Advanced Technology (IJEAT)
ISSN: 2249 – 8958, Volume-8 Issue-6, August, 2019
1947
Published By:
Blue Eyes Intelligence Engineering
& Sciences Publication
Retrieval Number F7928088619/2019©BEIESP
DOI: 10.35940/ijeat.F7928.088619
Abstract: Industrial gearboxes are designed for minimum 3 to 5
years of life considering normal working conditions. Theoretical
life of gearbox system can be predicted by calculating the life of
individual components of the gearbox like bearings, coupling and
gear-pair. There is significant amount of research work done on
estimating individual component life perdition however combined
life prediction of a gearbox is a quite complex phenomenon. The
challenge in developing a single life prediction model for variety
of gearboxes available in today’s market. There is a huge variety
in their types, sizes, costs, application conditions (indoor, outdoor,
marine, aerospace), safety requirements (domestic to hazardous).
Providing a common solution that address all these is near to
impossible. Major cause of early gearbox failure is wrong
selection for application, improper installation, contaminants and
excessive shock and impact loads. Vibration measurement gives
an early indication of failure of rotating parts in gearbox which
are primarily bearings and gear-pair. This research focuses on
step by step approach to calculate the life of bearings in a gear box
and gearbox life prediction models. The methodology followed can
be used for other types of industrial gearboxes.
Key words: American Bearing Manufacturers Association
(ABMA), American Gearing Manufacturers Association
(AGMA), Fast Fourier Transform (FFT), Rolling Contact
Fatigue (RCF)
I. INTRODUCTION
Gearbox life depends upon minimum life of its components.
Gear pair is designed for higher life as per the application for
which it is selected [1], [2]. Bearings are the most critical
components in deciding overall life of gearbox. Hence it is
important to understand causes of bearing failures and the life
prediction models of bearings[2], [3]. Both ABMA standard
and ISO 281 give detailed life prediction procedure.
Theoretically it can be proven that bearings can last almost
infinitely for a given application if they are properly
mounted, lubricated and kept free from contaminants.
However in real-life conditions this is not possible and
bearings early due to various reasons[4], [5] and [6]. Bearing
failures can be broken down in to two basic categories, one
premature failure where bearings don’t even run for
minimum life for which they are selected and second is the
fatigue failures where bearing run for sufficient time and then
fail. Many a times premature failures can be catastrophic
hence it is important to understand their root causes and make
a plan to avoid them in applications[3].
A. Causes of bearing failure –
i. Inadequate lubrication – about 43% of the bearings fail
due to inadequate lubrication which results due to insufficient
Revised Manuscript Received on August 22, 2019.
Ajeet Arvind Majali, Engineering, College of Engineering Pune,
Dr. Maheshwar Dinkar Jaybhaye, Production & Industrial
Management, College of Engineering Pune, Pune, India
or interrupted supply of lubrication or many a times wrong
selection of lubricants. Proper heat transfer from bearing hot
races to lubricant needs to be ensured, else bearings can fail
due to overheating[3].
ii. Improper installation – about 29% of the bearings fail
due to improper installation. The reasons for this could be
shaft or mounting defects, misalignment, incorrect fit of inner
race with shaft or outer race within housing, excessive
clearance, surface finish of mounting surface or housing,
excessive axial play, false brinelling due to vibrations, end
shield or bearing seal damage while mounting[3].
iii. Improper sealing – about 18% bearings fail due to
ineffective seals. This can be due to contaminants from inside
the lubricant or outside the bearings, moisture in the
lubricant, corrosion[3].
iv. Subsurface fatigue - about 8% bearings fail due to
subsurface fatigue. This can be due subsurface crack
development coming out of Rolling Contact Fatigue (RCF)
[8], [9]. The details of RCF are explained in section B.
v. Miscellaneous reasons – about 2% bearings fail due to
other miscellaneous reasons which can be due to an electric
current passing through bearings which are not properly
insulated, quality of bearing steel and impurities in bearing
steel processing. Vacuum degassed 52100 steel are most
popular bearing material. Also incorrect selection of bearing
can also result in premature failure. Bearing failure statistic
shown in table 1 gives the common causes of failure and their
% occurrence based on general industrial bearing failure
analysis[3].
B. Rolling Contact Fatigue –
Fatigue failures are due to rolling contact fatigue (RCF). RCF
theory for bearing material is not new, however it’s
interpretation and implementation in real-life bearings is
important [7]. Rolling contact fatigue failure is made up of
two dominant mechanisms, one is subsurface originated
spalling [9] and the other is surface originated pitting. First
step to avoid fatigue failures is to test the bearing steels using
rolling contact fatigue type testing. These type of testing
equipment are available and can be customized as per
customer needs. Most popular types of machines are rotary
tribometers which press the pins or balls on a rotating disk.
Different combinations like Ball-on-disk [24],
Cylinder-on-disk, Pin-on-disk, Cross cylinder,
Block-on-ring, Block-on-cylinder, Ball-on-ring, Linear
Reciprocating (Ball/Pin on Plate), ball on rod types are
available [3]. A constant load is applied on the material to be
evaluated. The material is either stationary or rotating based
on machine configuration. Load is applied using a standard
52100 vacuum degassed steel material either in the form of
balls or a flat plate.
Worm Gearbox Bearing Life Prediction
Ajeet Majali, M. D. Jaybhaye