Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Fusion Engineering and Design
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/fusengdes
Characterization of less common nitrides as potential permeation barriers
Jiří Matějíček
a,
⁎
, Jakub Veverka
a,b
, Vincenc Nemanič
c
, Ladislav Cvrček
b
, František Lukáč
a
,
Vladimír Havránek
d
, Ksenia Illková
a
a
Institute of Plasma Physics, Prague, Czech Republic
b
Czech Technical University Prague, Czech Republic
c
Jožef Stefan Institute, Ljubljana, Slovenia
d
Nuclear Physics Institute, Řež, Czech Republic
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Hydrogen permeation barriers
Physical vapor deposition
Nitrides
Permeation measurement
Adhesion
Residual stress
ABSTRACT
In a fusion reactor, the transport of hydrogen isotopes (primarily tritium) has to be controlled, from the point of
view of fuel balance and retention in the reactor components, which can result in material degradation and
spreading of radioactivity. To suppress this, tritium permeation barriers are developed. Suitable materials for the
permeation barriers are those with low hydrogen isotope permeability - primarily ceramic materials, such as
oxides, carbides and nitrides.
In this study, coatings of six less common nitrides prepared by physical vapor deposition – namely AlCrN,
CrN, Cr2N, CrWN, WN and ZrN – were investigated. Besides basic characterization (elemental and phase
composition, surface morphology and coating thickness), hydrogen permeation, adhesion, residual stress and
thermal expansion were evaluated. All coatings were dense, crack-free and well adherent. The permeation re-
duction factor which was determined at 400 °C and 1 bar ranged from ˜10
2
to ˜5 × 10
3
, the best performance
being achieved by the ZrN coating. As these materials seem not to be investigated as hydrogen permeation
barriers, they have a very high potential to be further improved.
1. Introduction
In nuclear fusion reactors, tight control of the hydrogen isotope
transport is indispensable. This stems on one hand from the need to
maintain an efficient fuel cycle (especially tritium breeding and re-
covery), on the other hand from the effects of hydrogen isotopes on the
materials – from radioactivity in case of tritium to degradation of me-
chanical properties (hydrogen embrittlement) [1,2]. The metals con-
sidered as structural materials for fusion devices, such as reduced ac-
tivation ferritic-martensitic steels, have very high permeability of
hydrogen isotopes, which increases with temperature [1]. Therefore,
permeation barriers have to be applied, while their principal role is to
suppress the permeation of hydrogen isotopes into structural materials.
The general requirements for permeation barriers are: the capability to
prevent or reduce hydrogen adsorption, low hydrogen diffusion rate
and the absence (or at least very low density) of pores, cracks and other
structural defects [3]. More specific requirements arise from the ap-
plication in a breeding blanket: high thermomechanical integrity,
compatibility with the breeder materials/corrosion resistance, applic-
ability to large engineering components [4,5]. Self-healing capability,
i.e. regeneration of the damaged barrier through in situ oxidation is also
a benefit. The performance of the permeation barriers is compared
through a permeation reduction factor (PRF), i.e. the ratio of permea-
tion of untreated and treated base metal. In a review by Hollenberg
et al. [6], required PRF values in the 10
2
-10
4
range are mentioned,
depending on specific design. In [7,8], similar values (˜10
2
) are pre-
sented from the point of view of breeder blanket operation.
Prospective candidate materials are ceramics – oxides, nitrides and
carbides, which often feature high temperature stability and corrosion
resistance, besides low hydrogen permeation [1,9]. A variety of de-
position techniques have been used, including physical vapor deposi-
tion (PVD), chemical vapor deposition (CVD), hot-dip aluminization
(HDA) + oxidation, electro-chemical deposition (ECD), plasma
spraying (PS), pack cementation, and others.
Oxides represent the most widely investigated class of materials for
permeation barriers. Their general advantage is that, in the environ-
ment with oxygen presence, the oxide layer might replenish or even
grow [10]. On the other hand, they often have significantly different
thermal expansion from the steels, which might result in spallation
and/or cracking upon high temperature exposure in service [3]. Among
them, the most popular is alumina, thanks to its low inherent perme-
ability [1,11,12]. More recently, erbia [13], chromia [14], zirconia [15]
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.fusengdes.2018.12.056
Received 19 October 2018; Received in revised form 13 December 2018; Accepted 18 December 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: matejicek@ipp.cas.cz (J. Matějíček).
Fusion Engineering and Design 139 (2019) 74–80
Available online 04 January 2019
0920-3796/ © 2019 The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T