Web accessibility policies at land-grant universities
David A. Bradbard
a,
⁎
,1
, Cara Peters
a,1
, Yoana Caneva
b,2
a
Management and Marketing, College of Business Administration, Winthrop University, United States
b
Winthrop University, United States
abstract article info
Article history:
Accepted 19 May 2010
Keywords:
Web design
Accessibility
Web accessibility
University policies
The Web has become an integral part of postsecondary education within the United States. There are specific
laws that legally mandate postsecondary institutions to have Web sites that are accessible for students with
disabilities (e.g., the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)). Web accessibility policies are a way for
universities to provide a general guide to action for faculty and staff that serve as Website developers for the
organization. The purpose of this study is to examine the extent and effectiveness of Web accessibility
policies at land-grant universities in the United States. To that end, this paper presents a conceptual
foundation for the study, ranging from an overview of Web accessibility studies, to legal mandates, to
literature on organizational policies. Data collection consists of a content analysis of the Web accessibility
policies of land-grant universities. Results show that while most universities have a Web accessibility policy,
most policies have serious deficiencies. The deficiencies are of sufficient magnitude that many schools are
likely in violation of the ADA and at risk for a law suit from a disabled person unless these policies are
strengthened.
© 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
For universities within the United States, the Web has become an
important tool for communicating with the various constituencies of
the institution. With respect to their primary audience, students,
universities extensively utilize the Web to communicate on both
academic and non-academic endeavors. With respect to the latter, it is
common for universities to provide Web sites for students to register
for classes, pay bills, order transcripts, access grades, check class
schedules, purchase books, and even buy event tickets.
On the academic side, the Web has become a significant part of
student experiences within and outside of the classroom (Clarke III,
Flaghtery, & Mottner, 2001). Faculty utilize the Web to support both
face-to-face instruction as well as distance learning (Benbunan-Fich,
Lozada, Pirog, Priluc, & Wisenblit, 2001; Eastman & Swift, 2001; Osika,
Johnson & Buteau, 2009; Wood, Solomon, & Allan, 2008). Lincoln
(2001) found more than 81% of university marketing faculty reported
creating and maintaining individual faculty Web sites. Furthermore,
Lincoln's data showed that the amount of material being placed on
academic Web sites had increased significantly over time. Since
Lincoln's (2001) study, the amount of instructional material being
placed on the Web has continued to swell, as two thirds of universities
now offer online courses. In offering both online and traditional
classroom based courses, faculty are increasingly reliant on technol-
ogy as part of their instruction (Osika, Johnson & Buteau, 2009; Smart,
Kelley, & Conant 2003). As part of their course work, students are
being asked to access Web sites to download course syllabi, Power-
Point slides, and assignments, among other materials (Clarke III et al.,
2001; Osika et al., 2009; Wood et al., 2008).
Since the role of the Web in the education of college students has
clearly increased over time, one might wonder how the use of the
Web for postsecondary education impacts students with disabilities.
Web accessibility is the practice of making Web sites accessible to
people who require more than just traditional Web browsers to access
the Internet. For example, a visually impaired student may use a
screen reader to translate text and graphics on the computer screen to
an audio format so he/she hears the Web site content via a speech
synthesizer. In an instructional setting an accessible Web site is
designed to accommodate a wider set of ways all students (disabled
included) can access a Web site's content.
As explained below, accommodating students with disabilities
(including Web accessibility efforts) is legally mandated for postsec-
ondary institutions. There are specific laws (e.g., Section 508) that
require federally funded institutions to have accessible Web sites.
Federally funded institutions include universities. Arguably, Sec-
tion 508 could be interpreted as applying at the level of individual
faculty Web sites that are created and utilized to support classroom
instruction. Thus, university faculty could be held responsible for
complying with the legal mandates of Web accessibility law for the
Internet and Higher Education 13 (2010) 258–266
⁎ Corresponding author. Department of Management and Marketing, College of
Business Administration, Thurmond Hall, Winthrop University, Rock Hill, SC 29733,
United States. Tel.: +1 803 323 4801; fax: +1 803 323 3960.
E-mail address: bradbardd@winthrop.edu (D.A. Bradbard).
1
Both authors made equal contributions to the paper.
2
Now at KPMG, Greenville, SC, United States.
1096-7516/$ – see front matter © 2010 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.iheduc.2010.05.007
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Internet and Higher Education