2010 VOL. 34 NO. 3 AUSTRALIAN AND NEW ZEALAND JOURNAL OF PUBLIC HEALTH 337
© 2010 The Authors. Journal Compilation © 2010 Public Health Association of Australia
Book reviews
coronary heart disease (Fig 1.13, p 54), cerebrovascular disease,
and lung cancer (Fig 1.15, p56) Australia fares well: 11
th
lowest of
34 for CHD and 3
rd
lowest for both CVD and lung cancer.
Comparative infant mortality rates for OECD and EU countries
from 1960 to 2006 shows the extraordinary universal more than
four-fold drop over the 50 years, whether from 20.2 to 4.7per
1000 live births for Australia or from 189.5 to 22.6 in Turkey.
Unfortunately, apart from citing the sources, denominators and
ascertainment issues are not discussed. Therefore, caution on
interpreting these data needs to be used. Comparative health costs
are also worthy of browsing.
All the data and figures are well and consistently presented.
With countries listed in alphabetical order in tables and ranked
by decreasing male prevalence in figures.
The likely purchasers for this valuable reference book are
Government departments, Pharmaceutical companies and
libraries. Given its UK focus, there would be limited use in
Australia. Unfortunately Public Health researchers would be
unlikely to be able to purchase it. As one researcher said to me
“it would be lovely to have on one’s bookshelf”.
doi: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00541.x
Donaldson’s Essential Public Health
(Third Ed)
By Liam J Donaldson and Gabriel Scally. Published by
Radcliffe Publishing, Oxford. 2009. ISBN 978184612098. 566
pages plus index. RRP $96.00
Reviewed by Max Watson
Retired public health nutritionist, Melbourne
This volume is a reincarnation of a long-established reference
originally written by the senior author, presently the UK’s Chief
Medical Adviser, with his late father in the 1980s. The current
authors have worked in remarkably diverse areas of interest,
too numerous to mention in this review and this experience has
been ably used. While the emphasis is on the health system in
the UK, generally it has universal relevance, especially as here
and elsewhere there is active debate as to how health services
can be efficiently provided in a modern economy. The work is
unashamedly proud of healthcare in the UK, but acknowledging
the need for evolution and engaging in how change might be
implemented.
This volume has breadth including epidemiology, strategies
for intervention to promote health and prevent disease and health
policy. Chapters also explore many contemporary challenges,
including provision of disability services, mental healthcare,
mother and child care and care of the elderly. New and emerging
diseases including potential pandemics are discussed. It is pleasing
that opportunity is frequently taken to place public health practice
in a historical context in the text, tables and figures.
Readers of this Journal are likely to engage with this text in a
range of ways. There may be at times frustration for some with
the emphasis on service provision within the National Health
Service. For many more the greater impact of public health
principles and practice within a system based on universal public
care will be appealing. The six vignettes in Chapter 2 describing a
variety of investigations of health service problems are a triumph.
These describe how a range of approaches can provide insight to
concerns such as, access to care for marginalised minority groups,
allocation of specialist services, functional capacity and survival
in the elderly, extended stay in hospital following trauma, child
abuse, and the impact of closure of large mental hospitals.
Often important concepts are only briefly described, a limitation
dictated by the scope of this book. The longest chapter concerns
infectious diseases dealing with the major issues including
principal diseases, causes of infection, and rare infections
including those acquired overseas. As with the book in general,
it is engaging and clearly presented and up-to-date, for example,
with passing reference to Hendra virus. This and other chapters
provide an overview of the subject matter that will facilitate a
background for further study. While introductory in content, the
detail is not superficial. The only errors observed were editorial
in nature. The authors could have encouraged readers to increase
their knowledge by providing suggested further readings, although
perhaps this is unnecessary in an era of Google Scholar.
This is an excellent ‘getting started’ text. Healthcare is now a
vital element in modern society and destined to be increasingly so.
Given that public health practitioners have a key and potentially
more important role in provision of health, this is a helpful
book. Hopefully it will be more widely accessed, by others with
responsibilities in the health sector as well.
doi: 10.1111/j.1753-6405.2010.00542.x
Primary Healthcare: People,
Practice, Place
By Valorie A. Crooks and Gavin J. Andrews. Published
by Ashgate, 2009. Hardcover: 272 pages, ISBN: 978-
0754672470. RRP $145.00
Reviewed by Victoria J. Palmer
Applied Ethicist, Primary Care Research Unit, The
Department of General Practice, The University of
Melbourne, Victoria
Crooks and Andrews’s Primary Healthcare: People, Practice,
Place sits within the geographies of health series and is a first of
its kind text. The series aims to introduce a largely under-addressed
subject (geography) in primary healthcare (PHC) research to
examine risk, representation, meaning, inequality, power, culture
and difference including health mapping and modelling. While
geographic information systems (GIS) have been employed in
health services research for mapping disparities in access and