Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
International Journal of Thermal Sciences
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ijts
Advanced numerical modeling of turbulent ice slurry flows in a straight pipe
Aurélien Bordet
a
, Sébastien Poncet
a,*
, Michel Poirier
b
, Nicolas Galanis
a
a
Université de Sherbrooke, Faculté de génie, Département de génie mécanique, 2500 Boulevard de l’Université, Sherbrooke, QC, J1K 2R1, Canada
b
Ressources naturelles Canada (CanmetÉnergie), 1615 Lionel Boulet, Varennes, QC, J3X 1S6, Canada
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Ice slurry
Numerical modeling
Isothermal flow
Turbulent dispersion
ABSTRACT
The present work aims at developing and assessing an advanced numerical model in order to investigate the
dynamic behavior of ice slurry flows under isothermal conditions. The transport equation proposed by Phillips
et al. [1] for solid suspension flows is used to describe the evolution of the particle volume fraction within the
flow. For turbulent flows, an original term is introduced to account for the turbulent dispersion of the particles.
The model has first been favorably compared to experimental data available in the literature for three types of
solid-fluid suspensions. It is also shown that it provides more accurate predictions than more complex two-phase
models. The numerical model has then been used confidently to investigate ice slurry flows. Four turbulence
closures have been compared in a numerical benchmark. The results obtained by the − k ω SST model have then
been compared for discussion to the analytical model of Kitanovski and Poredǒs [2] for eight sets of inlet flow
conditions. The present model is able to capture more complex flow features, especially the secondary flow and
the near-wall boundary layers.
1. Introduction
Ice slurries are a complex mixture of liquid water, ice particles and a
given additive used to lower the freezing point temperature of the
mixture. Progressively, they become a competitive alternative to con-
ventional secondary refrigeration systems due to the recent improve-
ments in ice slurry generator technology. Companies can now manu-
facture generators able to produce highly concentrated ice slurries
without ice agglomeration, especially using seawater (see the recent
review of Melinder and Ignatowicz [3]). As other phase changing
media, ice slurry allows to store and transport a very large amount of
“cold energy”. Egolf and Kauffeld [4] observed that the heat capacity of
ice slurries is eight times higher than the heat capacity of traditional
single-phase secondary refrigerants. For a given amount of transported
energy, the pumping energy consumption is then drastically reduced
compared to other secondary refrigerants and smaller equipment can be
used. The reduced freezing point temperature of the mixture enables to
improve the quality of the produced cold and to obtain a cooling pro-
cess with almost no temperature change. Ice slurries contain a very
small quantity of non-polluting additives, which makes them an effi-
cient refrigeration technology with a low environmental impact. They
have therefore been widely applied in various industrial applications
going from building cooling to food conditioning, or even in medical
protective cooling applications. The reader can refer to some review
papers [4–7] for more details.
More surprisingly, their local and/or time-dependent hydrodynamic
behavior still remains not fully understood. The thermal insulation of
the heat exchangers and the opacity of ice slurries, among other para-
meters, make the measurements of local velocity, temperature or ice
concentration difficult. During the last two decades, experiments con-
cerned mainly global measurements: pressure loss, mass flowrate, wall
temperatures or density among other things, both at the inlet and the
outlet of heat exchangers. Various operating conditions were con-
sidered in terms of flowrate, initial concentration of the additive and of
the ice particles, type of additive, geometrical configuration, thermal
boundary conditions … As examples, Renaud-Boivin et al. [8] per-
formed experiments in a shell and tube heat exchanger with an ethylene
glycol ice slurry flowing in the tubes and hot water in the shell and
Kumano et al. [9] investigated the flow and heat transfer characteristics
of ethanol ice slurry in the transition region. From experimental mea-
surements of the flowrate and the pressure loss, other authors deduced
rheological laws for ice slurry flowing in pipes [10] or more complex
geometries [11]. Reviews on the thermophysical properties of ice slurry
may be found in Refs. [4,12].
The lack of reliable local experimental data has slowed down the
development of innovative and dedicated numerical models. Ice slurry
flows are very challenging for numerical methods: multiphase flows,
non-Newtonian behavior, thermal imbalance between the different
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijthermalsci.2018.02.004
Received 13 March 2017; Received in revised form 26 November 2017; Accepted 6 February 2018
*
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: Aurelien.Bordet@USherbrooke.ca (A. Bordet), Sebastien.Poncet@USherbrooke.ca (S. Poncet), Michel.Poirier@canada.ca (M. Poirier),
Nicolas.Galanis@USherbrooke.ca (N. Galanis).
International Journal of Thermal Sciences 127 (2018) 294–311
1290-0729/ Crown Copyright © 2018 Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
T