LETTERS
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41550-017-0293-z
© 2017 Macmillan Publishers Limited, part of Springer Nature. All rights reserved.
1
Physical Research Laboratory, Ahmedabad, Gujarat 380009, India.
2
Tata Institute of Fundamental Research, Mumbai, Maharashtra 400005, India.
3
Inter-University Center for Astronomy and Astrophysics, Pune, Maharashtra 411007, India.
4
Indian Institute of Technology Bombay, Mumbai,
Maharashtra 400076, India.
5
Raman Research Institute, Bengaluru, Karnataka 560080, India.
6
National Centre for Radio Astrophysics, Pune, Maharashtra
411007, India.
7
Vikram Sarabhai Space Center, Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala 695002, India.
8
Indian Space Research Organization, Bengaluru, Karnataka
560231, India. *e-mail: santoshv@prl.res.in
The Crab pulsar is a typical example of a young, rapidly spin-
ning, strongly magnetized neutron star that generates broad-
band electromagnetic radiation by accelerating charged
particles to near light speeds in its magnetosphere
1
. Details
of this emission process so far remain poorly understood.
Measurement of polarization in X-rays, particularly as a func-
tion of pulse phase, is thought to be a key element necessary
to unravel the mystery of pulsar radiation
2–4
. Such measure-
ments are extremely difficult, however: to date, Crab is the
only pulsar to have been detected in polarized X-rays
5–8
and
the measurements have not been sensitive enough to ade-
quately reveal the variation of polarization characteristics
across the pulse
7
. Here, we present the most sensitive mea-
surement to date of polarized hard X-ray emission from the
Crab pulsar and nebula in the 100–380 keV band, using the
Cadmium–Zinc–Telluride Imager
9
instrument on-board the
Indian astronomy satellite AstroSat
10
. We confirm with high
significance the earlier indication
6,7
of a strongly polarized
off-pulse emission. However, we also find a variation in polar-
ization properties within the off-pulse region. In addition, our
data hint at a swing of the polarization angle across the pulse
peaks. This behaviour cannot be fully explained by the exist-
ing theoretical models of high-energy emission from pulsars.
The Cadmium–Zinc–Telluride Imager (CZTI) on-board the first
dedicated Indian astronomy satellite, AstroSat, is a coded aperture
telescope designed for hard X-ray observations, including polariza-
tion. The hard X-ray polarization measurement capability of CZTI
has been securely established by extensive ground calibrations using
partially polarized and, more importantly, unpolarized X-rays
11
.
Since the launch of AstroSat on 2015 September 28, the Crab nebula
has been extensively observed on 21 different occasions during its
first 18 months of operation and we use all observations in our analy-
sis. Since hard X-ray polarization measurements almost always have
limited statistical significance and can thus be affected by large sys-
tematic uncertainties, we have carefully validated all the steps in the
analysis procedure to extract the polarization signal (see Methods
for details). These steps include the selection of Compton events
for polarization analysis, selection and subtraction of the appro-
priate background component, normalization of the instrumental
modulation, co-addition of individual observations, and so on. One
very important validation step is the demonstration of the pulsed
signal in the Compton events selected for the polarization analysis
(as shown in Supplementary Fig. 1). We find that the pulse profile of
the Compton events closely matches the known double-peaked pulse
intensity profile in this energy range
12
, with the second peak stronger
than the first. Subsequent to this validation, we carried out a polar-
ization analysis following the procedure reported by Vadawale et
al.
11
. We found that all CZTI observations with a net exposure greater
than 50 ks yield a clear detection of polarization. In a few cases where
the individual exposures were lower, we co-added exposures from a
given month, resulting in eight independent datasets. The polariza-
tion fraction and angle derived from these eight datasets (Fig. 1a,b,
respectively) show a consistent behaviour. Two representative modu-
lation curves are shown in the insets of Fig. 1b (all modulation curves
are shown in Supplementary Fig. 5). When all Crab observations are
co-added, the resultant exposure time is ~800 ks and the measured
polarization fraction is 32.7 ± 5.8%, yielding detection at more than
5σ significance. For comparison, the minimum detectable polariza-
tion at the 99% confidence level for an 800 ks observation of a Crab-
like source with CZTI is around 10%. The measured position angle
is 143.5 ± 2.8° eastwards from the celestial north. For the off-pulse
region alone (a phase range of 0.82 to 1.18 as per our phase defini-
tion, which has an offset of 0.3 phase with respect to the phase defini-
tion used by Kuiper et al.
12
), our estimates of the polarization fraction
and polarization angle are 39.0 ± 10.0% and 140.9 ± 3.7°, respectively,
providing close to 4σ detection in the off-pulse region itself. Our
measured polarization fraction value is consistent with that obtained
by INTEGRAL (46 ± 10%) in the energy range of 0.1 to 1 MeV; how-
ever, the polarization angle is slightly higher than that reported by
INTEGRAL (123 ± 11°)
6
. Considering the fact that, at soft X-ray
energies, the polarization fraction is even lower (19.5 ± 2.8%) and
the polarization angle is farther away (152.6° ± 4.0°)
5
, this suggests
a systematic energy dependence of polarization properties. The co-
added modulation curves are shown in Fig. 1c,d for the total Crab
emission and the off-pulse emission alone, respectively. The confi-
dence regions shown in Fig. 1e (total Crab) and Fig. 1f (off-pulse)
demonstrate that these are the most precise hard X-ray polarization
measurements of the Crab so far.
The high significance of our polarization detection enables us
to examine the dependence of the polarization characteristics on
the pulse phase. Here, we are guided by the detailed phase-resolved
polarization study made at radio
13
and optical
14
wavelengths. In
particular, studies in the optical band
14
show that the off-pulse and
‘bridge emission’ (connecting the two peaks) have relatively steady
Phase-resolved X-ray polarimetry of the Crab
pulsar with the AstroSat CZT Imager
S. V. Vadawale
1
*, T. Chattopadhyay
1
, N. P. S. Mithun
1
, A. R. Rao
2
, D. Bhattacharya
3
, A. Vibhute
3
,
V. B. Bhalerao
4
, G. C. Dewangan
3
, R. Misra
3
, B. Paul
5
, A. Basu
6
, B. C. Joshi
6
, S. Sreekumar
7
,
E. Samuel
7
, P. Priya
7
, P. Vinod
7
and S. Seetha
8
NATURE ASTRONOMY | www.nature.com/natureastronomy