WILLIAM H. SACK, MORTON BEISER,
NORMAN PHILLIPS, AND GLORIA BAKER-BROWN
CO-MORBID SYMPTOMS OF DEPRESSION AND CONDUCT
DISORDER IN FIRST NATIONS CHILDREN: SOME FINDINGS
FROM THE FLOWER OF TWO SOILS PROJECT
ABSTRACT. The prominence of co-morbidity in children and adolescents has increased
over the past decade as new empirical research data has accumulated. Yet little
epidemiological data of any kind exists for First Nations Children. Following a brief
literature review on co-morbidity in children and adolescents, the authors analyzed data
from the Flower of Two Soils Project (M. Beiser, principal investigator) to examine more
closely the relationship between self-reported depressive symptoms and parent/teacher
reported conduct symptoms. Such a relationship has been consistently found in a number
of studies. Children aged 7 to 10 were found to show more academic and social problems
when rated as having high conduct symptoms. Children in the co-morbid group were
found to have the highest rates of family stress and help-seeking behavior. Suicidal
ideation was as high in the conduct and co-morbid groups as it was in the high depression
group. More First Nations children were found in the high conduct-low depression group.
The significance of these findings is discussed.
INTRODUCTION
While definitive prevalence rates for psychopathology in both First Nations
children and non-native children have yet to be determined, the existing
evidence strongly suggests that they are not parallel. Compared to non-native
children, Beiser and Attneave (1982) showed that First Nation children appear to
come under an increasing risk of emotional disorder as they move from
childhood to adolescence. First Nation children's academic achievement appears
to deteriorate at about the same stage of development (Bryde 1966). More
recently, Dinges (1991) and Ackerson et al. (1990) have shown very high rates
of affective disorder in boarding school groups of First Nations adolescents.
Manson (1990), who reviewed the existing literature, found First Nations
adolescents to have overall suicide rates two to three times higher than their
non-native counterparts.
Despite our lack of overall basic epidemiological knowledge in this area, the
current empirical evidence does suggest that co-morbidity is frequently found in
clinical samples of children and adolescents (Woolsten et al. 1987) and com-
munity samples as well (McGee 1984, Lewinsohn et al. 1991). As DSM-III-R is
now being extensively used to make clinical diagnoses, one finds it much less
difficult to distinguish psychopathology from normality in children and
adolescents, but much more difficult to distinguish various categories within
DSM-III-R (McClellan et al. 1990). As studies proceed, questions of whether
co-morbid conditions are more stable than single diagnoses, whether they lead to
Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 16: 471-486, 1993.
© 1993 KluwerAcademic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.