Copyright © 2017 American College of Occupational and Environmental Medicine. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited
Effect of Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction Training
on Health Care Worker Safety
A Randomized Waitlist Controlled Trial
Morgan Anne Valley, MPH, PhD and Lorann Stallones, MPH, PhD
Objective: The study assessed the impact of mindfulness training on
occupational safety of hospital health care workers. Methods: The study
used a randomized waitlist-controlled trial design to test the effect of an
8-week mindfulness-based stress reduction (MBSR) course on self-reported
health care worker safety outcomes, measured at baseline, postintervention,
and 6 months later. Results: Twenty-three hospital health care workers
participated in the study (11 in immediate intervention group; 12 in waitlist
control group). The MBSR training decreased workplace cognitive failures
(F [1, 20] ¼ 7.44, P ¼ 0.013, h
2
p
¼ 0:27) and increased safety compliance
behaviors (F [1, 20] ¼ 7.79, P ¼ 0.011, h
2
p
¼ 0:28) among hospital
health care workers. Effects were stable 6 months following the training.
The MBSR intervention did not significantly affect participants’
promotion of safety in the workplace (F [1, 20] ¼ 0.40, P ¼ 0.54,
h
2
p
¼ 0:02). Conclusions: Mindfulness training may potentially decrease
occupational injuries of health care workers.
H
ospital health care workers have a high occupational injury
rate. In the United States, hospital health care workers had an
annual incidence rate of 6.0 recordable non-fatal injuries per 100
full-time equivalent (FTE) employees in 2015, which represents a
rate higher than the all-industry non-fatal occupational injury and
illness incidence rate (3.3/100 FTE).
1
Research has suggested that in
additional to the physical pain and damage caused by an injury
incident, occupational injuries affect mental and social well-being
through increased stress, family conflict, and decreased daily
functioning.
2
Protecting and promoting occupational safety and
health among health care professionals is especially important, as
evidence suggests that improving aspects of health care worker
well-being and safety not only predicts health care worker injuries
and clinician job satisfaction, but also reduces medical errors and
increases patient satisfaction.
3–5
Given the far reaching impact of health care worker safety
and health, researchers, practitioners, and government organizations
have called for the creation and evaluation of practical interventions
that promote both health care worker occupational safety and
overall well-being.
6
These scholars and practitioners hope that such
interventions will also ultimately improve patient safety and quality
of care. The current study responds to this call by testing
mindfulness training, generally used as a stress reduction and
wellness promotion program among health care providers,
7
as an
intervention intended to impact health care worker safety outcomes.
Mindfulness is defined as ‘‘a receptive attention to and
awareness of present events and experience.’’
8
While normal func-
tioning involves awareness and attention, mindfulness, entails
heightened, nonjudgmental awareness, and attention.
8
Mindfulness
training, which involves increasing a person’s ability to attain
nonjudgmental awareness in the present moment,
9
has been increas-
ingly incorporated into workplace wellness programs leading to
positive outcomes among workers.
10–13
Mindfulness-based stress
reduction (MBSR) interventions in particular have had success in
reducing negative outcomes among health care workers including
anxiety, depression, and perceived stress levels.
7,14–19
The MBSR
program, developed at University of Massachusetts Medical School,
trains participants to incorporate mindfulness into their daily lives.
20
The well-validated program consists of eight 2.5- to 3.5-hour
weekly group sessions and one longer (typically 6 to 8 hours) silent
retreat session. The sessions consist of training and practice in
mindfulness meditation, informational presentations on topics such
as stress physiology, group discussions, and home assignments that
promote practicing the skills learned in the program.
21
A recent review of the role of mindfulness in the workplace
found that a growing body of evidence supports a positive associ-
ation between mindfulness and attention stability, control, and
efficiency, which in turn impacts cognition, emotion, behavior,
and physiology.
11
These impacts have implications for workplace
safety outcomes, including workplace cognitive failure and safety
performance. Workplace cognitive failure refers to cognitively-
based errors that occur during the performance of a work task that
an individual can normally successfully complete.
22
A decline in
workplace cognitive failure can lead to a decline in safety perform-
ance and an increase in workplace injuries.
Safety performance consists of two factors: safety compli-
ance and safety participation.
23
Safety compliance refers to personal
safety behaviors including adherence to established workplace
safety procedures and rules. Safety participation refers to safety
behaviors that are external to an employee’s role, such as offering
suggestions on how to improve workplace safety and promoting
overall safety within the workplace. A longitudinal study of hospital
employees found that as health care workers’ self-reported safety
performance increased, the number of injuries in the workplace
decreased.
24
The reduction in injuries occurred at the group level,
Learning Objectives
Become familiar with recent research on mindfulness-based
stress reduction (MBSR) interventions for healthcare workers,
and their potential effects on workplace safety.
Summarize the study design and the MBSR training
intervention evaluated.
Identify specific safety-related outcomes that were and were
not affected by the MBSR intervention.
From the Department of Psychology (Dr Valley, Dr Stallones); Graduate Degree
Program in Public Health, Colorado School of Public Health at Colorado
State University (Dr Stallones); High Intermountain Plains Center for
Agricultural Health and Safety (Dr Stallones), Colorado State University,
Fort Collins, Colorado.
Funding: The study was partially funded by a small grant from NIOSH through
the Mountain and Plains Education and Research Center.
Authors Valley and Stallones have no relationships/conditions/circumstances that
present potential conflict of interest.
The JOEM editorial board and planners have no financial interest related to this
research.
Address correspondence to: Morgan Anne Valley, MPH, PhD, Department of
Psychology, Colorado State University, Sage Hall, Fort Collins, CO 80523-
1879 (Morgan.Valley@colostate.edu).
Copyright ß 2017 American College of Occupational and Environmental
Medicine
DOI: 10.1097/JOM.0000000000001090
JOEM Volume 59, Number 10, October 2017 935
CME A VAILABLE FOR THIS ARTICLE AT ACOEM.ORG