Adaptive Behavior
Book Review
Adaptive Behavior
2024, Vol. 0(0) 1–13
© The Author(s) 2024
Article reuse guidelines:
sagepub.com/journals-permissions
DOI: 10.1177/10597123231225511
journals.sagepub.com/home/adb
Review of Thomas Fuchs—In Defense of the
Human Being
Review of Thomas Fuchs – In Defense of the Human Being. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021, ISBN 9780192898197.
Reviewed by: Mark M James
Handling Editor: Russell Meyer, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China
Machine with the strength of a hundred men
Can’t feed and clothe my children; Can’t greet a sailor
coming in
Or know of desperation
Lisa O’Neill
1. Introduction
Amongst the books on my shelves, one in particular de-
viates from the typical pattern. It is entitled The SAS Sur-
vival Handbook and is, somewhat ironically, easily
recognizable by the camouflaged pattern that is the primary
motif of its cover and the shocking neon orange of the title
text—quickly locatable in an existential pinch! Written by
former British special forces member and now “survival
consultant,” John “Lofty” Wiseman, it is, by all accounts, a
classic. I purchased the book 15 years ago during a period
when I was playing with the idea of living a more self-
sufficient existence. Despite keeping it on my shelf all this
time, I’ve never done more than skim its pages. Luckily,
I’ve never had to. I simply trust the Amazon reviews that
should the need ever present itself, I will be glad to have it.
Reading Thomas Fuchs’ s (2021) In Defense of the
Human Being (IDHB) puts me in mind of Wiseman and his
classic text. Fuchs, as well being Karl Jaspers Professor for
Philosophical Foundations of Psychiatry and Psychotherapy
at the University of Heidelberg, is also a practicing psychiatrist
and the medical director of the Blankenburg Day Clinic in
Heidelberg. Like Wiseman, Fuchs knows his subject up close.
But IDHB is also a survival manual of sorts. Indeed, one, oddly
enough, with a lot more application in our current age than
Wiseman’ s. I say this, for having lived with IDHB for a while
now its value has been reaffirmed repeatedly and compounded
with time. The number of times I have drawn on insights from
it during an exchange, instructed my conversation partners that
they must read it, or returned to it in the wake of a chat in which
I couldn’t quite bring some vital insight to mind, far exceed any
other text I have read in recent years, maybe even ever.
Of course, like with any survival manual, one hopes that
with a bit of time, and a bit of luck, it will become un-
necessary and gather dust on a shelf somewhere, seeming
quaint and out of touch. If I had to bet though, IDHB will
remain in active service for some time to come. The nar-
ratives it defends against are only growing in prevalence and
power, and few books are likely to match IDHB in the
power of the criticism it directs toward them.
The narratives referred to have been organizing around a
couple of dominant cultural, intellectual, and techno-
scientific attractors for some time now. One concerns the
ideas of biological determinism and the neuroreductionism
that accompanies it, which tends to squeeze out any pos-
sibilities for real subjectivity, that is, the kind that makes a
difference. In short, it does so by reducing every event of a
living experiencing being to the pre-determined unfoldings
of a meaningless meat machine. The other narrative relates
to the ideas of transhumanism and the neuroconstructionism
that underpins much of it. Transhumanism is an emerging
global culture that, at base, views the mind as independent
from the body and seeks to transcend the human being and
all its bodily inconveniences for an existence free not only
from the limitations of the body itself, but of the rhythms
and restrictions of life altogether. It is against these narra-
tives and their consequences that Fuchs’ s sees his defense of
Embodied Cognitive Science Unit, Okinawa Institute of Science and
Technology Graduate University, Japan