Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Structural Safety
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/strusafe
Damage index fragility assessment of low-rise light-frame wood buildings
under long duration subduction earthquakes
Yuxin Pan
a,b,
⁎
, Carlos E. Ventura
a
, Thomas Tannert
b
a
Earthquake Engineering and Research Facility, Department of Civil Engineering, The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
b
Wood Engineering, University of Northern British Columbia, Prince George, BC, Canada
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Fragility curve
Structural damage
Ground motion duration
Subduction earthquake
Incremental dynamic analyses
ABSTRACT
This paper presents fragility curves for conventional low-rise light-frame wood buildings in southwestern British
Columbia, Canada, for long duration subduction earthquakes. Computational models of four representative two-
story houses (two engineered and two non-engineered) are developed and validated using full-scale shake table
testing data. Damage states are evaluated using the Park and Ang damage index. Incremental dynamic analyses
are employed for calibrating and assessing the index. Duration efects are investigated by using 30 long duration
subduction motions and 30 “spectrally equivalent” short duration crustal motions. The results indicate that the
considered houses are more vulnerable to damage under subduction motions which increase the median damage
indices of both individual shearwalls and entire lateral systems for all four houses at the same level of ground
shaking. The correlation between system damage indices with ground motion duration was dependent on the
level of ground shaking and the seismic resistance of the systems. The results further demonstrate that exterior
stucco fnish greatly reduces the seismic damage and can be used as an efective seismic retroft strategy for
conventional non-engineered wood construction.
1. Introduction
1.1. Seismicity in British Columbia
The southwestern (coastal) part of British Columbia (BC) lies in one
of the most seismically active regions in Canada. This region is char-
acterized by three types of earthquakes, namely i) shallow crustal
earthquakes (happening within the crust of the North American con-
tinental plate), ii) sub-crustal earthquakes (triggered within the sinking
oceanic Juan de Fuca Plate), and iii) subduction earthquakes (triggered
at the interface between two plates - the Cascadia subduction zone) [1],
as shown in Fig. 1. It has been reported that at least 7 large subduction
earthquakes (Mw > 9) have occurred in the Cascadia subduction zone
over the past 3500 years [2]. The last major event has been dated to
January 26th, 1700. Recent studies by Goldfnger [3] indicated that
these large earthquakes have a recurrence interval of approximately
430 years. On this basis, some seismologists expect a similar subduction
event to hit the west coast of Canada in the near future which could
potentially endanger life, structures and infrastructure in southwestern
BC [2].
Engineers and researchers are facing many challenges in dealing
with subduction earthquakes. Subduction records are normally
associated with large magnitude and long duration [1,5]; their long
period characteristics could negatively afect base-isolated and high-
rise buildings [6]. One aspect of subduction earthquakes which has not
been thoroughly investigated is the link of their long duration with
structural damage. Typically, shallow crustal ground motions last no
longer than tens of seconds, while subduction motions can last several
minutes. Recent studies that focused on the collapse capacity of struc-
tures have demonstrated that long duration motions can signifcantly
increase the collapse rates of various types of building structures, such
as reinforced concrete frame, steel moment frame, and masonry
buildings [7–10]. However, few studies have been conducted on da-
mage states other than collapse, especially for wood structures that
have highly nonlinear behavior and signifcant ability to dissipate
hysteretic energy.
1.2. Light-frame wood buildings in British Columbia
According to the 2016 Census of Canada [11], over 95% of all re-
sidential buildings in Canada are of light-frame wood construction. Of
the approximately 1.9 million households in BC providing shelter to 4.6
million occupants, about 44% (830,660) of these units are single-family
homes and 42% (793,045) are apartment or condominium units
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.strusafe.2020.101940
Received 27 May 2019; Received in revised form 25 January 2020; Accepted 26 January 2020
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: ypan@civil.ubc.ca (Y. Pan).
Structural Safety 84 (2020) 101940
0167-4730/ © 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T