Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Materials Processing Tech.
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jmatprotec
Efect of a moving automated shot peening and peening parameters on
surface integrity of Low carbon steel
AL-Mokhtar O. Mohamed
⁎
, Zoheir Farhat, Andrew Warkentin, James Gillis
Dalhousie University, Canada
ARTICLEINFO
Associate Editor: Z Cui
Keywords:
Shot peening
Peening saturation
Peening coverage
Peening parameters
Peening efect
Almen strip
ABSTRACT
Shot peening is a widely utilized process in industry. It helps to increase fatigue and stress corrosion resistance
by creating benefcial compressive residual surface stresses of materials. Whilst very good results are achieved
with this process, there is always an increasing demand by industry and material researchers for improved
material surface quality, system reliability, and consistency controls of the process. First main objective of this
workwastostudytheefectofanautomatedmovingshotpeeningprocessonthesurfaceintegrityoflowcarbon
steelmaterial.Secondobjectivewastodiscussandpresentpeeningsaturationandintensityresultsandmodelin
anewapproachintermsofpeeningspeedsalongsidethetraditionalprocedurewhichshowspeeningsaturation
andintensityresultsintermsofpeeningtimes.Thirdobjectiveofthisstudywastoexaminetheefectsof:process
air pressure, nozzle stand-of distance, nozzle speed, and peening angle on coverage, saturation, and surface
quality utilizing the moving shot peening. This study showed that 276kPa air pressure, 203mm stand-of dis-
tance, and 5.3mm/sec nozzle speed are the optimum conditions for the shot peening process parameters ex-
amined on standard Almen strips samples which resulted in minimize surface irregularities, maximize com-
pressed layer thickness and uniformity, and minimize process time.
1. Introduction
The shot peening process is a widely used as a mechanical surface
treatment in the aerospace and automotive industries. The process is
benefcial forincreasingresistancetofatigue,stresscorrosioncracking,
hydrogen-assisted cracking, and wear, as well as for mitigating pro-
blems associated with surface and near surface porosity as reported in
the work of, among others, Mahagaonkar et al. (2008), Kim et al.
(2014),and Vielmaetal.(2014).Shotpeeninginvolvesbombardingthe
surface of a component with a stream of small particles with high
hardness, called shots. The process induces work-hardened and results
in a compressed surface layer (Kirk and Fall, 2007; Zhan et al., 2013;
Vielmaetal.,2014).Theintensityofpeeningisdefnedbytheamount
of energy (in the form of compressive residual stress) induced into the
part and is measured according to an industry standard known as the
Almen test. The test uses standardized steel test strips – Almen strips
(KirkandFall,2007).TheAlmenstripsareexposedtoashotstreamfor
varying amounts of time. Shot peening induces compressive stress on
onesideoftheAlmenstripthatcausesthestriptobendintoanarc.The
height of the arc is measured and is referred to as the intensity. In-
tensity,asafunctionofpeeningexposuretime,isplottedandisreferred
to as the saturation curve. Saturation is said to have occurred when
doubling the exposure time results in no more than a 10% increase in
intensity. Often the desire to guarantee 100% part coverage results in
over-peening of the component leading to a reduction of peening ben-
efts (Bagherifard et al., 2012; Sakamoto et al., 2015). Over-peening
maygiverisetosurfacedamageandadropinfatiguelife,inspiteofan
increase in surface hardening and deeper compressive residual stress
felds (Vielma et al., 2014). Furthermore, the compressive stress pro-
duced during shot peening at the surface induces tensile stresses in the
coreofthepart(Koeneckeetal.,1982).Thecombinedefectsoftensile
stresses and embrittlement provide the right conditions for crack nu-
cleation and propagation in the surface, which ultimately can result in
delamination (Kim et al., 2014). Over-peening transfers fatigue crack
nucleation from the surface to the subsurface and with a signifcant
increase in Almen intensity, more fatigue cracks may form (Cecchin
et al., 2014; Liu et al., 2009). Over-peening may also induce excessive
surface damage, such as burrs, micro-cracks, micro-laps, and micro-
folds.Thesesurfacedefectscreatestressconcentrationsthatmayreduce
fatigue performance.
Many researchers have performed optimization studies on the shot
peening process. For instance, Wang et al. (2008) developed an opti-
mization model that provided preliminary peening parameters for a
given shape. The optimization methodology was based on fnding
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmatprotec.2019.116399
Received 26 July 2018; Received in revised form 9 September 2019; Accepted 16 September 2019
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mokhtar.o.m@dal.ca (A.-M.O. Mohamed).
Journal of Materials Processing Tech. 277 (2020) 116399
Available online 17 September 2019
0924-0136/ Crown Copyright © 2019 Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T