On the Electronic Structure of NLi
2
and PLi
2
, Ground and Low-Lying Excited States
Demeter Tzeli, Aristotle Papakondylis, and Aristides Mavridis*
Laboratory of Physical Chemistry, Department of Chemistry, National and Kapodistrian UniVersity of Athens,
P.O. Box 64004, 15710 Zografou, Athens, Greece
ReceiVed: September 12, 1997; In Final Form: December 3, 1997
The ground states of the isovalent molecules NLi
2
(X ˜
2
Π
u
) and PLi
2
(X ˜
2
B
1
), along with some low-lying excited
states (
2
B
2
,
4
Σ
g
-
,
2
Σ
g
-
,
4
Σ
u
-
,
2
Σ
u
-
, and
2
A
1
), have been examined using ab initio CISD, CASSCF, and MRCI
methods in conjunction with relatively large correlation consistent basis sets. We report total energies,
geometries, binding energies, Mulliken charges, energy gaps, and for certain states, potential energy curves.
All states examined are bound with respect to the ground-state atoms N or P(
4
S) + 2Li(
2
S), while the mean
binding energies N-Li and P-Li of NLi
2
and PLi
2
are 42.5 and 40.2 kcal/mol, respectively.
1. Introduction
In the present report we examine via ab initio methods the
electronic structure of the ground state and of some low-lying
excited states of the isovalent molecules dilithium nitride (NLi
2
)
and dilithium phosphide (PLi
2
). To the best of our knowledge
there are no experimental or theoretical results in the literature
for NLi
2
. The PLi
2
system has been observed in the gas phase
by Knudsen-effusion mass spectrometry,
1
along with other
phosphorus-lithiated species. We are also aware of some, as
yet unpublished, ab initio results by Kudo
2
on the ground states
of PLi and PLi
2
molecules (vide infra). On the other hand,
experimental results on lithiated N- and P-species in the solid
state have existed for quite a few years.
3
The interest in these
systems is due to their ionic nature and the role they could
potentially play as solid-state ionic conductors.
Using SCF, CISD(+corrections), CASSCF (complete active
space SCF), CASSCF+1+2 (CASSCF + single + double
replacements ) MRCI), and MRCI+corrections methods in
conjuction with rather large correlation consistent basis sets,
we have examined the ground states X ˜
2
Π
u
(NLi
2
) and X ˜
2
B
1
-
(PLi
2
), as well as the low-lying excited states
2
B
2
,
2
Σ
g
-
,
2
Σ
u
-
,
2
A
1
,
4
Σ
g
-
, and
4
Σ
u
-
for both title molecules. In an effort to
better understand the nature of the chemical bond in these
unusual species, we have also constructed potential energy
curves (PECs) for certain states; in particular for the ground
2
Π
u
state of NLi
2
we constructed PECs referring to both
dissociation channels, NLi
2
f NLi + Li and NLi
2
f N + 2Li.
The present report is a continuation of our work on lithiated
species;
4
we believe that the simplicity of the Li atom (one active
electron), in parallel with its low-lying first excited state
(ΔE(
2
Pr
2
S) ) 1.85 eV), presents an ideal case for the study
of the chemical bond.
2. Basis Sets and Methods
For all atoms, the correlation consistent polarized basis sets
of Dunning were used, cc-pVnZ, where n is a cardinal number
characterizing the basis set quality.
5,6
One of the nicest
properties of the cc-bases is their potential of improving in a
well-defined and systematic way the quality of calculation and
their convergence toward the “complete basis set” limits of
various molecular properties within the methodology employed.
7
For the N and P atoms the quadruple n ) 4 (QZ) quality
basis was employed but with the functions of g-symmetry
removed (cc-pVQZ-g). For the N atom only and in conjuction
with the CISD method, the augmented cc-pVQZ-g (cc-pVQZ
+ one diffuse function for each symmetry present ) aug-cc-
pVQZ-g) was used. For the Li atom the n ) 3(TZ) basis was
selected. For instance, the PLi
2
basis set reads as follows:
(16s11p3d2f/(11s5p2d1f)
2
) f [6s5p3d2f/(4s3p2d1f)
2
], com-
prised of 110 contracted spherical Gaussians (i.e., five d and
seven f functions). The reason for selecting these particular
bases, e.g., n ) 4 for the N and P atoms and n ) 3 for the Li
atom, will be discussed further in the next section.
As was already mentioned, the theoretical methodologies
employed are SCF, CISD(SCF+1+2), CASSCF, and CASS-
CF+1+2 (MRCI). In the CASSCF calculations, the Li 2s-, N
2s2p-, and P 3s3p-like orbitals were included in the active space.
The Li 1s-, N 1s-, and P 1s2s2p-like orbitals were optimized
but always constrained to be doubly occupied. Given those
restrictions, our CASSCF space for the triatomic species contains
seven active orbitals and seven (valence) electrons. Depending
on the symmetry of the state, the size of the CAS space ranges
from 112 (
4
Σ
g
-
) to 404 (
2
A
1
) CSFs, with 988 665 and 1 501 544
CSFs, respectively, in the MRCI space. No corrections for basis
set superposition errors were applied, assuming that the size of
the basis sets was large enough. It should also be mentioned
that the size extensivity error in all MRCI PECs studied was
less than 0.1 mhartree.
Our computations were performed with the COLUMBUS
8
suite, with some CISD results checked by the MELD
9
code.
Also, the MOLPRO
10,11
code was used for certain calculations
on the diatomic molecule NLi.
3. Results and Discussion
a. The Diatomics NLi and PLi. Recently we have reported
on the ground and low-lying states of NLi
4b
and PLi
4a
molecules.
With the purpose of selecting basis sets of adequate size for
the triatomic species NLi
2
and PLi
2
, while at the same time
keeping our calculations manageable, we have reexamined the
dissociation energies (D
e
) and bond lengths (r
e
) of NLi and PLi
ground states as a function of basis set size. Our results at the
MRCI level, along with literature results, are reported in Table
1. Considering the D
e
and r
e
as the most sensitive parameters
2223 J. Phys. Chem. A 1998, 102, 2223-2230
S1089-5639(97)02998-8 CCC: $15.00 © 1998 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 02/28/1998