Effect of Random Sampling on Noisy Nonsparse
Signals in Time-Frequency Analysis
Isidora Stankovi´ c
GIPSA Lab/Faculty of Electrical Engineering
University Grenoble Alpes/University of Montenegro
Grenoble, France/Podgorica, Montenegro
isidoras@ac.me
Miloˇ s Brajovi´ c, Miloˇ s Dakovi´ c
Faculty of Electrical Engineering
University of Montenegro
Podgorica, Montenegro
{milosb,milos}@ac.me
Cornel Ioana
GIPSA Lab
University of Grenoble Alpes
Grenoble, France
cornel.ioana@gipsa-lab.grenoble-inp.fr
Abstract—The paper examines the exact error of randomly
sampled reconstructed nonsparse signals having a sparsity con-
straint. When signal is randomly sampled, it looses the property
of sparsity. It is considered that the signal is reconstructed
as sparse in the joint time-frequency domain. Under this as-
sumption, the signal can be reconstructed by a reduced set
of measurements. It is shown that the error can be calculated
from the unavailable samples and assumed sparsity. Unavailable
samples degrade the sparsity constraint. The error is examined
on nonstationary signals, with the short-time Fourier transform
acting as a representative domain of signal sparsity. The pre-
sented theory is verified on numerical examples.
Index Terms—compressive sensing, nonsparse signals, random
sampling, time-frequency analysis
I. I NTRODUCTION
Nonstationary signals are dense in both time and frequency,
when considered separately. They can be localized in the time-
frequency domains. However, they could be located within
much smaller regions in the joint domain using appropriate
representations [1]–[6], with the short-time Fourier transform
(STFT) being the basic transformation. The signals are sparse
in the time-frequency domain if the number of nonzero coef-
ficients in this domain is much smaller than the total number
of coefficients.
According to the compressive sensing (CS) theory, sparse
signals can be reconstructed using less samples/measurements
than required by the sampling theorem [7]–[12]. Reducing the
number of measurements will introduce noise in the analysis
of the signals. The properties of the noise from [13], [14]
will be used to define reconstruction properties in the case of
randomly sampled STFT. If a nonsparse signal is reconstructed
with a reduced set of available samples, then the noise due
to the missing samples of nonreconstructed coefficients will
be considered as an additive input noise in the reconstructed
signal.
Because of its nonstationary nature, signals in time-
frequency domain are usually approximately sparse or non-
sparse. In the CS literature, only the general bounds for the
reconstruction error for nonsparse signals (reconstructed with
the sparsity assumption) are derived [9], [15]–[17]. In this
paper, we present an exact relation for the expected squared
error, reconstructed from a reduced set of signal samples,
under the sparsity constraint. The error depends on the number
of available samples and the assumed sparsity. In order to be
more compatible with the practical problems, we will consider
that the signals are randomly sampled, i.e. not on the grid.
Also, signals with additive noise will be considered. Since the
signal is not on the grid, it looses the property of sparsity in the
transformation domain. The properties of uniform sampling
without noise are examined in [18]. The effects of random
sampling and noise are illustrated and checked on examples.
The paper is organized as follows. The theory of random
sampling in time-frequency analysis using the compressive
sensing framework will be explained in Section II. The influ-
ence of nonsparsity in randomly sampled signal will be shown
in Section III. Examples will be given in Section IV and the
conclusions are presented in Section V.
II. THEORETICAL BACKGROUND
A. Random sampling
Consider a general form of a multicomponent signal
x(t)=
C
l=1
x
l
(t), (1)
with C non-stationary components x
l
(t), l =1, 2,...,C . The
signal is of a time-varying nature. Although not sparse in
the Fourier transform (FT) domain, it may be sparse in the
joint time-frequency domain. In this paper, we assume that
the signal is sparse in the STFT domain, which is defined as
S
N
(t, Ω) =
∞
-∞
x(t + τ )w(τ )e
-jΩτ
dτ, (2)
where w(τ ) is the window function with duration T , centered
at point t. The periodic extension of the product x(t + τ )w(τ ),
for a given t can be expanded in Fourier series as follows
x(t + τ )w(τ )=
1
N
N-1
k=0
X
t
(k)e
j2πk(τ -T/2)/T
, (3)
with series coefficients X
t
(k) being equal to the discrete FT
(DFT) coefficients if x(n+m)w(m) is used to denote x(nΔt+
2018 26th European Signal Processing Conference (EUSIPCO)
ISBN 978-90-827970-1-5 © EURASIP 2018 485