THYROID
Volume 13, Number 10, 2003
© Mary Ann Liebert, Inc.
Ultrasound-Guided Laser Thermal Ablation in the Treatment
of Autonomous Hyperfunctioning Thyroid Nodules and
Compressive Nontoxic Nodular Goiter
Stefano Spiezia,
1
Giovanni Vitale,
2
Carolina Di Somma,
2
Angelo Pio Assanti,
1
Antonio Ciccarelli,
2
Gaetano Lombardi,
2
and Annamaria Colao
2
Objective: Percutaneous laser thermal ablation (LTA) has been applied in several tumors. In this study we eval-
uated the safety and long-term efficacy of LTA in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules. Design and patients:
Seven patients with autonomous hyperfunctioning thyroid nodule (group A) and five patients with compres-
sive nodular goiter (group B) were treated with LTA. Up to three needles were positioned centrally in the thy-
roid nodule and laser fiber was placed in the lumen of the needle. Laser illumination was performed reaching
a maximal energy deposition of 1800 J per fiber. Measurements: Thyroid nodule volume, endocrinologic, and
clinical evaluation were performed at baseline, 3, and 12 months after the treatment. Scintigraphy was per-
formed at diagnosis and 12 months after the first session in group A. Results: In group A, mean thyroid vol-
ume decreased from 3.15 6 1.26 mL to 0.83 6 0.49 mL (p , 0.001) after 12 months. The treatment induced dis-
appearance of clinical signs and symptoms related to hyperthyroidism; normalization of free triiodothyronine
(FT
3
), free thyroxine (FT
4
), and thyrotropin (TSH) serum levels and recovery of extranodular uptake at scinti-
scan. In group B, mean thyroid volume decreased from 11.14 6 4.99 mL to 3.73 6 1.47 mL (p , 0.01) after 12
months. Pressure symptoms in the neck, difficulty in swallowing and tracheal displacement improved in all
patients. The treatment was well tolerated in both groups of patients. Conclusions: LTA appears to be a valid
and safe alternative approach in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules.
941
Introduction
T
HYROID NODULE is a common disorder with a prevalence
ranging from 5%–50%. This wide range depends on the
population studied as well as the sensitivity of detection
methods (1,2). Most thyroid nodules are benign lesions. The
therapeutic strategy for treatment benign nodules includes
several options. Surgery is usually advised in toxic or if ma-
lignant nodular goiter is suspected, in large nodules (. 3 cm
in diameter) with pressure symptoms, or in nodular goiter
for cosmetic concerns (3,4). Radioiodine is a simple, cost-ef-
fective, and safe procedure in the treatment of autonomously
hyperfunctioning thyroid nodule (5,6). In addition, radioio-
dine may be recommended to treat large, nontoxic multi-
nodular goiters in patients who decline surgery or who are
at high surgical risk (7). Medical therapy includes levothy-
roxine therapy at thyrotropin (TSH)-suppressive doses and
thionamides. Levothyroxine-suppressive therapy is indi-
cated in young patients with small solid cold nodules and
normal thyroid function (8,9). Thionamides can normalize
free triiodothyronine (FT
3
), free thyroxine (FT
4
), and TSH
concentrations in toxic nodules. These agents are used to in-
duce euthyroidism before definitive therapy is performed
(10). Percutaneous intranodular ethanol injection (PEI) has
been described by several authors as alternative treatment
of toxic thyroid nodules, cysts, and large nontoxic thyroid
nodules (11–28).
Several authors have recently proposed interstitial laser
thermal ablation (LTA) as a new therapeutic method for thy-
roid nodules (29,30). It is a minimally invasive interventional
procedure able to induce thyroid tissue ablation.
We herein report the results of a preliminary study
undertaken to assess safety and usefulness of LTA treat-
ment in patients affected by single autonomous hyper-
functioning thyroid nodule and in euthyroid patients
with compressive nodular goiter, evaluating the effects of
this therapy on nodule volume, biochemical and clinical
benefit.
1
Department of Surgery, Ultrasound Guided & Neck Pathologies Surgery Unit, “S. Maria del Popolo degli Incurabili” Hospital ASL
NA1, Naples, Italy.
2
Department of Clinical and Molecular Endocrinology and Oncology, “Federico II” University of Naples, Naples, Italy.