High order decay equations, without any equilibrium assumptions and allowing
any initial progeny presence, analyzed precisely with mathematical code.
Visualizing High-Order Decay after
Disequilibria
Charles A. Wilson IV,
1
Katherine R. Hendrickson,
2
Amin M. Hamideh,
3
Kenneth L. Matthews II,
4
and Wei-Hsung Wang
5
Abstract: High-order decay equations are of-
ten difficult to study without significant care
taken with variables and assumptions. As par-
ent and progeny activities evolve over time, the
effects of uncertainties and approximations con-
found the quality and interpretation of results.
Of particular concern is the situation when decay
equilibrium has been disturbed and progenies
have arbitrary initial activities. To address this,
code was created using Wolfram Mathematica
to visualize the time-activity plots of the high or-
der progenies of naturally occurring radioactive
material after secular equilibrium is disturbed.
The Bateman equation for an un-replenished
parent was expanded to calculate activity vs.
time for up to 13 progenies at different initial ac-
tivities. The code uses the formula of Skrable
et al., without parent production, expanded to
the 13th progeny with arbitrary initial concen-
tration. The code calculates and plots activity
vs. time; it also reports the cumulative disinte-
grations of each progeny over a user-specified
time period for comparison to counting measure-
ments. The code could also be modified to incor-
porate additional production or branched decay
schemes. We believe this code may be useful to
health physicists and is intended to be accessible
for anyone’s use. This paper presents the code
with explanations and examples on how to use it.
Health Phys. 115(6):791–796; 2018
Key words: operational topics; decay chain;
naturally occurring radionuclides; spectrome-
try, gamma
INTRODUCTION
High-order Bateman equations are
commonly used in health physics
to calculate parent and progeny
activities. Typically, the Bateman
equation can be solved relatively
easily in closed form under condi-
tions of equilibrium or that of a
pure parent. Yet a complete solu-
tion that allows for more compli-
cated boundary conditions can
better be used to facilitate the un-
derstanding and visualization of
the temporal behavior of progeny
activities during more complicated
high order decay.
In situations where either it is
known that progenies exist but are
not in equilibrium with the parent
or something disturbs equilibrium
during processing the Bateman
equation is more difficult to apply.
This commonly occurs when one
wants to compare calculations to
experimental measurements. A
simplifying assumption such as
equilibrium may not be true; while
equilibrium may exist in the en-
vironment, sample collection or
preparation may cause some prog-
eny activity to be lost. An example
of this issue is naturally occurring
radioactive materials (NORM) that
contain gaseous progenies (e.g.,
uranium and thorium decay se-
ries). These gaseous progenies can
escape if the sample is not sealed
properly. The escape of radon gas
during sample preparation is used
as an example for this work.
When disequilibrium occurs,
an acceptable practice is to seal
the sample and wait for equilib-
rium to be restored. Unfortunately,
waiting some time to reestablish
equilibrium before making mea-
surements is not time efficient,
especially for a decay chain with
long-lived progenies. Although
some techniques are available to
shorten the waiting time (Li et al.
2015), approximations may limit
the accuracy of results. The full
Bateman equation is necessary to
correctly predict activity of the
parent or progenies in a non-
equilibrium situation.
This project was motivated by
a difficulty to find software or code
that models radioactive transfor-
mation when the original decay
chain does not have a pure parent.
This search focused on online
published solutions for n
th
order
Bateman equations, especially those
that allow arbitrary initial progeny
concentrations. While a variety of
resources were discovered, few of
these offer the ability to specify ar-
bitrary initial progeny activities
and often are limited to only a
1
J. Bennett Johnston Sr. Center for Advanced Micro-
structures and Devices (CAMD), Louisiana State Uni-
versity, 6980 Jefferson Highway, Baton Rouge, LA
70806;
2
University of Florida Department of Industrial
and Systems Engineering, 1819 Lewis Turner Blvd, Ft
Walton Beach, FL 32547;
3
Louisiana State University
Radiation Safety Office, 112 Nuclear Science Building,
Baton Rouge, LA 70803;
4
Louisiana State University
Department of Physics and Astronomy, 202 Nicholson
Hall, Baton Rouge, LA 70803;
5
Louisiana State Uni-
versity Center for Energy Studies, 1067 Energy, Coast
and Environment Building, Baton Rouge, LA 70803.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Charles A. Wilson IV is the radiation safety officer at Louisiana State University’s
Center for Advanced Microstructures and Devices (CAMD). He is currently a doctoral
candidate studying environmental health physics in the Department of Environmental
Sciences at LSU. He earned his master’s degree in medical physics and health
physics from LSU in 2012. Charles was President of the Deep South Chapter of the
HPS and a former Chair of the HPS Student Support Committee. He presently
serves as Chair of the Society Support Committee and member on the IRPA task
force. His email is cwils35@LSU.edu.
Operational Topic
Operational Radiation Safety www.health-physics.com 791
Copyright © 2018 Health Physics Society. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.