July 2023 703 Volume 22 • Issue 7
Copyright © 2023 BRIEF COMMUNICATION Journal of Drugs in Dermatology
SPECIAL TOPIC
Minimizing Bias in Alopecia Diagnosis
in Skin of Color Patients
Eliza Balazic BS,
a*
Eden Axler BS,
a*
Christy Nwankwo BA,
b
Randie Kim MD,
c
Kristen Lo Sicco MD,
c
Kseniya Kobets MD,
a*
Prince Adotama MD
c*
a
Division of Dermatology, Department of Medicine, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Montefore Medical Center, Bronx, NY
BUniversity of Missouri Kansas City School of Medicine, Kansas City, MO
c
The Ronald O. Perelman Department of Dermatology, NYU Grossman School of Medicine, New York, NY
*
Authors Balazic and Axler contributed equally. Drs. Adotama and Kobets contributed equally.
Alopecia is one of the most common dermatologic conditions affecting Black patients, with a signifcantly negative impact on quality
of life.
1,2
Timely and accurate diagnosis is therefore critical in order to reverse or halt progression of disease.
3
Unfortunately, lack of
representation of skin of color (SOC) patients in the current literature may contribute to misdiagnosis as providers may be unfamiliar
with the clinical spectrum of alopecia presenting in darker scalps.
4
Some scarring alopecia subtypes such as Central Centrifugal
Cicatricial Alopecia (CCCA) are more prevalent in certain racial groups. However, focusing solely on patient demographics and gross
clinical fndings may obscure accurate diagnoses. To distinguish alopecia fndings in Black patients, a dedicated approach using a
combination of clinical exam fndings and patient history, along with trichoscopy and biopsy, is essential to prevent misdiagnosis and
improve clinical and diagnostic outcomes. We present three cases of alopecia in patients of color which the initial suspected clinical
diagnosis did not correspond with trichoscopic and biopsy results. We challenge clinicians to reexamine their biases and fully evaluate
patients of color with alopecia. An examination should include a thorough history, clinical examination, trichoscopy, and potentially a
biopsy, particularly when fndings do not correlate. Our cases highlight the challenges and disparities that exist in diagnosis of alopecia
in Black patients. We emphasize the need for continued research regarding alopecia in skin of color and the importance of a complete
workup for alopecia to improve diagnostic outcomes.
J Drugs Dermatol. 2023;22(7):703-705. doi:10.36849/JDD.7117
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION
A
lopecia is one of the most common dermatologic
conditions affecting Black patients, with a signifcantly
negative impact on quality of life.
1,2
Timely and
accurate diagnosis is therefore critical in order to reverse or halt
progression of disease.
3
Unfortunately, lack of representation
of skin of color (SOC) patients in the current literature may
contribute to misdiagnosis as providers may be unfamiliar with
the clinical spectrum of alopecia presenting in darker scalps.
4
In particular, vertex alopecia in SOC patients can be subject to
bias as certain scarring alopecias, such as central centrifugal
cicatricial alopecia (CCCA), occur at a higher prevalence
in patients of African descent
5
and classically presents as
hair loss in the vertex of the scalp.
6
Other forms of alopecia
may present with vertex involvement in patients of color, so
clinicians should fght the urge to jump to a diagnosis of CCCA
without performing a thorough examination. Trichoscopy, or
scalp dermoscopy, allows dermatologists to evaluate alopecia
based on visualization of morphologic patterns and can
provide diagnostic clues to help clinicians avoid misdiagnosis
of alopecia. Key studies have defned trichoscopic fndings in
SOC.
7,8
While trichoscopy does not replace the need for biopsy,
it is a critical tool in the initial evaluation of hair loss.
We aim to highlight the importance of challenging bias in
the clinical diagnosis of alopecia in SOC. The diagnosis of
alopecia based on gross clinical morphology alone can lead
to misdiagnosis of alopecia type in Black patients. Barriers to
early diagnosis must be reduced to ensure quality care is given
to patients of all racial backgrounds. Herein, we present three
cases of vertex alopecia in which the initial suspected clinical
diagnosis did not correspond with trichoscopic and biopsy
results. To distinguish alopecia fndings in Black patients, a
dedicated approach using a combination of clinical exam
fndings and patient history, along with trichoscopy and biopsy,
may be essential to prevent misdiagnosis and improve clinical
and diagnostic outcomes.
doi:10.36849/JDD.7117
Do Not Copy
Penalties Apply
To order reprints or e-prints of JDD articles please contact sales@jddonline.com
This document contains proprietary information, images and marks of Journal of Drugs in Dermatology (JDD).
No reproduction or use of any portion of the contents of these materials may be made without the express written consent of JDD. If you feel you
have obtained this copy illegally, please contact JDD immediately at support@jddonline.com
JO07022