65
Real and Literary Landscapes in Ancient Egypt
Real and Literary Landscapes in Ancient Egypt
Judith Bunbury & David Jefreys
During the past thirty years the Survey of Memphis and others have acquired more than
two hundred borehole logs from the Capital Zone of Egypt. Combining these boreholes with
maps and satellite images, we show that, during the past fve thousand years, the geography
of the Nile has been in constant fux with mean rates of migration around 2 m/y and one
of its channels becoming extinct, by nature or through human intervention. Re-visiting
ancient texts in the light of this changing environment, we show that the literary setings
of both fctional and historical texts were real landscapes known to the authors. Hence we
infer that ancient descriptions of landscape can be interpreted in a more literal way than
before and that the authors were not as prone to writing of a metaphorical realm as was
previously thought.
past 12,000 years since the last ice age. These lines of
evidence include, detailed borehole records from Lake
Yoa in Chad (Kröpelin et al. 2008), borehole studies
by Stanley & Warne (1993) and geoarchaeological
evidence collected by the Survey of Memphis (Jefreys
& Bunbury 2005).
The Memphite foodplain has been explored by
the Survey of Memphis who have made around 140
borehole records during the period 1985–2009 that
reveal the past geomorphology. The interpretation
of satellite imagery (Lutley & Bunbury 2008; Hillier
et al. 2007) and topographic maps also reveals the
geometry of the changing foodplain and a model for
the direction and rate of river migration. Typically for
this part of the Nile, the bends migrate outwards and
downstream with the channel migrating at a rate of
around 2 km per millennium. Thus, since our earliest
text from the Middle Kingdom, channels could have
crossed the foodplain from one side to the other.
Combining this evidence with that from the boreholes
we can construct a map of these past landscapes and
their waterways.
By focusing on texts that describe the Memphis
area, the site of an important scribal school, through
time we are able to compare the way in which the
rapidly changing landscape is described by the texts
and by the sediments.
Landscape descriptions and imagery are compara-
tively rare in ancient Egyptian literature. Those that do
exist are ofen difcult to place in the known landscape
and have thus been characterized as mythical land-
scapes. Some geographical narratives are quite clearly
fantastical, and were meant to be so (e.g. the ‘Story of
the Shipwrecked Sailor’: Papyrus Leningrad 1115).
Recent studies of landscape evolution in the
Memphite foodplain of northern Egypt (Fig. 1) allow
us to redraw the maps of the region for each period.
Thus literature such as the ‘Prophecy of Amenemhat’,
the ‘Tale of Sinuhe’, and the later ‘Stele of Piye’
can be more confdently placed in the landscape in
which they were writen. Comparison of the ancient
geography of the relatively well-known Memphite
area with the landscapes of the texts reveals that
they represent a more literal approach to landscape
in ancient literature than previously supposed. In
addition, some perceived difculties with the texts
can be clarifed by reference to the local geography
of the time. We note also that texts where the fullest
landscape descriptions occur are generally assumed
to have a fctional component and perhaps relied on
their realistic seting for their credibility.
In this work we provide a context for the examina-
tion of selected texts by reviewing the geological and
geographical evidence for landscape changes over the
Cambridge Archaeological Journal 21:1, 65–75 © 2011 McDonald Institute for Archaeological Research
doi:10.1017/S0959774311000047 Received 11 Jan 2010; Accepted 20 May 2010; Revised 19 Jul 2010
https://doi.org/10.1017/S0959774311000047
Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. Open University Library, on 20 Jan 2017 at 06:53:07, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms.