American Journal of Applied Sciences 3 (4): 1785-1789, 2006
ISSN 1546-9239
© Science Publications 2006
Corresponding Author: Bassam Al-Helou, Al-Isra University-Faculty of Engineering, Al-Isra University P.O Box 99,
11266 Amman, Jordan
1785
The Economic Feasibility of Rebuilding Al-Isra University Tunnel – Mechanical Factors
Bassam Al-Helou
Al-Isra University-Faculty of Engineering, Al-Isra University P.O Box 99, 11266 Amman, Jordan
Abstract: Economic feasibility is the cornerstone in the decision making on an economic venture. The
more positive the economic signs, the less the risk and foreseen losses. This study throws light on
some economic advantages of rebuilding Al-Isra tunnel, especially in terms of shortening the car/bus
trip by six kilometers go and fro, and in terms of reducing the trip schedule by five minutes. That is by
using an alternative road through one of the present tunnels available on the way to the university. The
study makes also a comparison between the construction cost and the emanating benefits in terms of
saving time and vehicle operation. The sensitivity analysis shows that the B/C ratio is 3.05, and in
worst cases it is 2.03. While these results definitely prove the economic feasibility of the project, they
also point to the risk reduction of traffic accidents, due to road shortening.
Key words: Economical feasibility, tunnel rebuilding, mechanical factors, sensitivity analysis
INTRODUCTION
Al-Isra University lies on Queen Alia International
Airport Road, some 27 kilometers from Amman city
centre to the south. In its vehicle schedule, Al-Isra
looks unique among the state and private universities.
Due to the desert nature of the area, and the scarcity of
inhabitation communities, south to the university,
vehicles tend to go north toward Amman, while they
run along the road to the airport across Al Qastal Bridge
when destined to university. In this very case, vehicles
would have passed the university campus and thus turn
on a parallel road, and subsequently lengthen their
distance to the university.
Since several tunnels are located on the road before
vehicles can come to the university, the renovation of
one of them is possible with a view to shortening the
two way distance. This study presents a proposal for
achieving this goal by reforming one of the closest
tunnels to Al-Isra University. It also argues about the
economic consequences of this project.
Project Description: The idea behind this project is to
find an alternate shorter road for vehicles destined to
Al- Isra University. The projected road will use the
nearest tunnel to the university, and will cut the vehicle
trip by six kilometers, and its scheduled time by five
minutes as drivers are usually obliged to slow down to
make a turn, or run over a bridge, in order to finally
enter a course parallel to the highway.
Figure (1) shows the required shortened distance
both ways between the reconstructed tunnel and the
university. The red line in the drawing shows the
vehicle direction to the university across Al Qastal
Bridge, then makes a turn to the campus, whereas the
white line shows the return direction of the vehicle
from the university to the north; i.e. to Amman.
Figure (2) specifies the road proposed to cross
through the reconstructed tunnel up to the campus. The
red line in the drawing the road will be used by the
university and staff vehicles after the tunnel’s
reconstruction, while the white line indicates the
vehicles return trip from the university to Amman.
Noteworthy is the fact that by the white line there
would be no need for the vehicles to go through the
reconstructed tunnel, in their return trip, as the
reconstructed road meets with the highway.
Fundamentals of the Study
[1,2]
:
Data base:
No. of faculty members, 166.
No. of staff members, 340.
No. of vehicles, 52.
Assumptions: The average salary of the faculty
members is 900 Jordanian Dinar (JD).
The average salary of staff members is 250 JD
The working hours of faculty members are (5-6) hours.
The month is 23 days.
The year is 11 months.
The values are approximated to Jordanian Dinar.
The project’s construction cost: The distance between
the reconstructed tunnel and the university campus is
approximately one kilometer long. Half of this road
needs to be paved, and the other half repaved at six
meters wide. According to current cost estimates in
other similar construction projects, one square
meter of road pavement costs JD5, thus making
the total construction cost about JD 30 000,