Vol.:(0123456789) 1 3
Transp. in Dev. Econ. (2017) 3:14
DOI 10.1007/s40890-017-0044-y
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Development of a Need-Based Approach for Rural Road Network
Planning
Shalini Kanuganti
1
· Bhupali Dutta
1
· Ashoke Kumar Sarkar
1
· Ajit Pratap Singh
1
Received: 8 March 2016 / Accepted: 16 June 2017
© Springer International Publishing AG 2017
Introduction
Road construction has always been considered impor-
tant for rural development, but the rational approach of
road construction has changed over time. In the 1960s and
1970s, roads were seen as an asset in economic growth by
connecting areas of potentially proftable agriculture [4, 9].
The perspective of rural transportation planning in develop-
ing countries has changed from a ‘road-and-car’ approach
to a ‘needs-led’ approach [11]. There is a lack of basic
understanding of defning the actual role of rural roads in
the overall road network hierarchy in developing countries
[10].
Keeping in view the importance of transport, [4] argues
that the development of primary necessary infrastructure
alone does not ensure poverty alleviation in rural areas and
will not totally help in achieving the Millennium Develop-
ment Goals (MDG) in Africa.
Connectivity in rural areas based on demand doesn’t
ensure accessibility to basic facilities. Moreover, the devel-
oping countries have large number of small settlements for
example in India, there are about 0.6 million villages and
many of them have very small population. The demand
pattern in rural areas being quite low, connecting villages
based on population isolates habitations with less popu-
lation and in the long run they are deprived of economic
and social development. Hence, demand-based approach
of connecting villages may not be appropriate; rather a
need-based network approach providing accessibility to all
the villages to basic facilities would be more appropriate.
The Rural Roads Development Plan: vision 2025 has also
suggested the development of network-based approach for
connecting habitations with small population [19]. Build-
ing need-based network for providing accessibility to facili-
ties could be efective in increasing economic potential,
Abstract Road connectivity has a catalytic efect on the
economic and social development and poverty alleviation
in rural areas. In most of the developing countries, prior-
ity of connection is entirely based on demand. But mere
connectivity does not satisfy accessibility to basic needs.
In this paper an attempt is being made to develop a need-
based approach for rural connectivity which would ensure
accessibility to the basic facilities. Using GIS platform, a
network was developed using need-based approach on it.
Similarly using the demand-based connectivity network
was prepared. Then both the networks were compared. It
was found that the need-based network was connecting
more number of villages and providing better accessibility
though the length was higher. The paper has suggested that
it is not necessary to construct high quality roads for each
link and depending on the usage and population served they
could be constructed as earth, gravel or black top/concrete
roads. Considering the budgetary constraints a methodol-
ogy has also been suggested to prioritize the construction
of the links.
Keywords Rural transportation · Need-based network ·
Demand-based network · Accessibility
* Shalini Kanuganti
shalini.kanu@gmail.com
Bhupali Dutta
bhupali08@gmail.com
Ashoke Kumar Sarkar
aksarkar@bits-pilani.ac.in
Ajit Pratap Singh
aps@pilani.bits-pilani.ac.in
1
Civil Engineering Department, Birla Institute of Technology
and Science Pilani, Pilani 333031, India