Energy Conversion and Management 229 (2021) 113735
0196-8904/© 2020 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Sustainable three-stage chemical looping ammonia production
(3CLAP) process
M.M. Sarafraz
*
, F.C. Christo
School of Engineering, Deakin University, Waurn Ponds, Geelong, Victoria, Australia
A R T I C L E INFO
Keywords:
Three-stage ammonia production
Thermal plasma
Chemical looping
Metal nitride, green process
ABSTRACT
In the present paper, a new CO
2
-neutral thermodynamic process is developed based on a chemical looping
principle that circulates nitrogen carrier between reactors for producing ammonia and/or hydrogen via a ni-
trogen fxation reaction. This study advances the knowledge on selecting plausible nitrogen carrier candidates
from a wide range of metals including rare and transient elements. The proposed three-stage chemical looping
ammonia production (3CLAP) system consists of two exothermic reactors: nitridation and ammoniation reactors
to drive the nitrogen fxation reactions, and an endothermic thermal plasma reactor to handle dissociation of
metal oxides back into a pure metal that is re-circulated in the process. The heat released in the nitridation and
ammoniation reactors is recovered to generate electricity, which partially meets the energy demand of the
thermal plasma unit. Several key criteria were used in the thermochemical analysis for selecting suitable metals
for the 3CLAP process; the spontaneity of the reactions, melting temperature of the metals, availability of metals,
energetic performance of heat recovery unit, and the nitrogen and steam economy. It was identifed that chrome
(Cr), magnesium (Mg), aluminium (Al), calcium (Ca), and manganese (Mn) were the best nitrogen carrier metals
amongst all candidates. Chrome yielded the highest nitrogen economy of molar ratio (NH
3
/N
2
) of ~ 1.97 and the
highest steam economy (NH
3
/H
2
O) of ~ 0.98. However, the lowest performance of nitrogen and steam economy
was for Mn of ~0.96, and ~0.3, respectively. With chrome, the power block effciency was ~ 32.3%, which is a
competitive value to the current state-of-the-art effciencies reported in the literature. The highest self-sustaining
factor (SSF) was ~ 0.33, meaning that one-third of the total energy demand of thermal plasma reactor could be
delivered via a heat recovery system.
1. Introduction
Ammonia is one of the most promising chemicals for storing and
transporting hydrogen safely [1]. The current global ammonia produc-
tion is around 162 million metric tons per annum, which is partitioned
to produce agricultural nitrogen-based fertiliser and nitric components
for supporting >50% of global food production [2]. Commercialised
pathway for ammonia production is predominantly through the Haber-
Bosch (H-B) process, which requires high pressure (~200 bar), high
temperature (200 to 300
◦
C), and expensive catalysts such as rhodium,
nickel [3] or iron [4]. The spent catalysts require cyclic regeneration and
re-activation, which adds to the complexity and cost of the process.
Required hydrogen for the Haber-Bosch process is usually supplied from
methane reforming process [5], which utilises several reforming re-
actors that are energy-intensive and contributes to global warming by
releasing CO
2
and NO
x
to the environment [6]. Despite these
disadvantages, ammonia is still produced commercially through the H-B
process because there is no other economically viable and cleaner
pathway for synthesis of ammonia. As mentioned earlier, the H-B pro-
cess is an energy-intensive process [7], and process-wise is based on
centralised nitrogen fxation production plant with limited effciency
and high energy consumption of 1 MJ/mol of N
2
[8].
Chemical looping gasifcation and chemical looping hydrogen pro-
duction are two viable pathways for effcient conversion of fossil fuels
into clean hydrogen or ammonia. Hence, signifcant effort has been
made to improve the chemical performance and effciency of these
systems to reach competitive level to existing reforming systems for
hydrogen production. Recently, Pereira et al. [9] assessed a chemical
looping process for producing 500 kt/y of ammonia from methane in-
tegrated with a CO
2
separator unit. They chose packed bed as a plausible
confguration for the reactors and yielded 1.54–1.63 kg NH
3
per kg
methane. Together with this, the system consumed up to 2.32 MJ/kg
CO
2
to separate carbon dioxide from ammonia. They concluded that the
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: mohsen.sarafraz@deakin.edu.au (M.M. Sarafraz).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy Conversion and Management
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/enconman
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2020.113735
Received 26 October 2020; Received in revised form 22 November 2020; Accepted 1 December 2020