Performance Bounds Analysis for Semi-Blind Channel Estimation with Pilot
Contamination in Massive MIMO-OFDM Systems
Ouahbi Rekik
*
, Abdelhamid Ladaycia
*
, Karim Abed-Meraim
†
and Anissa Mokraoui
*
*
L2TI, Institut Galilée, Université Paris 13 Sorbonne Paris Cité, France
{ouahbi.rekik, abdelhamid.ladaycia, anissa.mokraoui}@univ-paris13.fr
†
PRISME, Université d’Orléans, France
karim.abed-meraim@univ-orleans.fr
Abstract—Pilot contamination, in a massive Multiple-Input
Multiple-Output (MIMO) system, is an undeniable challenging
issue severely affecting the performance of the system by
including channel estimation errors. The aim of this paper is
to investigate the effectiveness of semi-blind channel estimation
approaches in massive MIMO-OFDM (Orthogonal-Frequency
Division-Multiplexing) systems. For an estimator-independent
study, the performance analysis is carried out using the Cramér
Rao Bound (CRB) derivation for pilot-based and semi-blind
channel estimation strategies. This analysis demonstrates in
particular that: (i) when considering the finite alphabet nature
of communication signals, it is possible to efficiently solve the
pilot contamination problem with semi-blind channel estima-
tion approach; and (ii) the Second Order Statistics (SOS) only
are not sufficient to address the full channel identifiability even
if the semi-blind approach is considered.
1. Introduction
Massive Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) is a
promising technology for the next generation cellular net-
works [1]. With a higher number of Base Station (BS)
antennas (beyond 100 antennas), compared to the classical
MIMO systems, massive MIMO technology has proven its
ability to improve the spectral and power efficiency [2]. So
that, both throughput and reliability will be highly enhanced
for the future cellular networks.
In order to fully exploit all of the potentials offered by a
massive MIMO system, accurate Channel State Information
(CSI) is necessary. It is obtained only during the uplink
transmission, thanks to the channel reciprocity property and
according to the widely accepted Time Division Duplexing
(TDD) protocol. The traditional methods to get the CSI rely
on the pilot-based channel estimation (see e.g. [1]). How-
ever, due to the non-orthogonality of the pilot sequences,
these methods are severely affected by what is called pilot
contamination [3]. It is one of the major issues of massive
MIMO systems that must be addressed because its effect
cannot be reduced by increasing the number of BS antennas.
Many pilot contamination mitigation strategies have been
proposed: creating more orthogonal pilots by slicing the
time and frequency resources [4], subspace projection-based
interference suppressing [5], data-aided channel estimation
[6], or by designing appropriate inter-cell communication
protocols and resource allocation. In recent works (e.g. [7],
[8]), a particular attention has been drawn to blind and semi-
blind methods. The former is fully based on the statistical
properties of the transmitted data, whereas the latter depends
on the joint use of pilots and data.
The focus of this paper falls into the scope of perfor-
mance analysis of semi-blind channel estimation with pilot
contamination in the context of multi-cell massive MIMO-
OFDM systems. For an estimator-independent performance
analysis, the Cramér Rao Bound (CRB) is derived for both
pilot-based and semi-blind channel estimation. Note that
a thorough study has been conducted in [9] where the
achievable performance of semi-blind approaches compared
to pilot-based ones has been quantified for channel es-
timation in a MIMO-OFDM system. This study will be
extended to a massive MIMO-OFDM system, by taking into
account the multi-cell context and the phenomenon of pilot
contamination.
The rest of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2
describes the massive MIMO-OFDM system model. Section
3 illustrates the pilot contamination effect. The derivation
of the CRB for pilot-based and semi-blind approaches are
detailed in section 4. Simulation results are discussed in
section 5. Finally, Section 6 concludes the work.
2. Massive MIMO-OFDM system model
This section presents the massive MIMO-OFDM wire-
less system adopted in this paper. An uplink transmission
is considered. The system is composed of N
c
cells where
each cell contains one BS with N
r
antennas and N
t
users
using each a single antenna. The received signals from the
adjacent cells are initially ignored. Therefore the received
signal at the r-th BS antenna of the l-th cell, assumed to be
a K sub-carriers OFDM signal, is given by [9]:
y
l,r
=
Nt
i=1
F T (h
l,i,r
)
F
H
K
x
l,i
+ v
l,r
, (1)
where the superscript (.)
H
denotes the Hermitian operator;
K is the OFDM symbol length; F represents a K-point
2018 26th European Signal Processing Conference (EUSIPCO)
ISBN 978-90-827970-1-5 © EURASIP 2018 1277