Global NEST Journal, Vol 7, No 1, pp 1-16, 2005
Copyright© 2005 Global NEST
Printed in Greece. All rights reserved
MODELING BROMIDE EFFECTS ON THE SPECIATION OF
TRIHALOMETHANES FORMATION IN CHLORINATED DRINKING WATER
K.M. MOK
1
*
H. WONG
2
X.J. FAN
2
1
Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering
University of Macau, Av. Padre Tomás Pereira S.J., Taipa
Macau
2
The Macau Water Supply Co. Ltd.
718, Avenida do Conselheir Borja, Macau
Selected from papers presented in 9
th
International Conference on
Environmental Science and Technology
(9CEST2005)
1-3 September 2005, Rhodes island, Greece
* to whom all correspondence should be addressed:
tel: (853) 3974354, fax: (853) 838314
e-mail: kmmok@umac.mo )
ABSTRACT
Speciation behavior of trihalomethanes formation in chlorinated waters due to the effects
of bromide is mathematically modeled by a three-tier scheme. Equations for the mole
fractions of the mono-, di-, and trihalo-intermediates at each tier level in terms of the initial
bromide to chlorine molar ratio are derived and verified by comparison with results of
other theoretical studies based on an assumption of constant bromination to chlorination
reaction reactivity ratio. It is identified that the usage of applied chlorine concentration or
available chlorine concentration for calculation of the relative initial bromide to chlorine
concentration would yield different reactivity ratio and should be used consistently. The
model equations are also tested by laboratory experiments done with source water at a
local plant. It is found that equations with an overall bromination to chlorination rate
constant ratio of 18.66 can capture the THM speciation behavior of all four tested
incubation periods well.
KEYWORDS: Trihalomethanes; Speciation; Bromide effects; Kinetic model; Drinking
water
1. INTRODUCTION
Chlorination is a common process used for disinfection of drinking water in the world. It is
a process using chlorine to destroy pathogenic bacteria and algae in raw water. This
process has only been considered as a life-saver until Rook (1974) and Bellar et al. (1974)
showed that potent trihalomethanes (THMs) of four species can be formed as disinfection
by-products in chlorination. They are Chloroform (CHCl
3
), Bromodichloromethane
(CHBrCl
2
), Dibromochloromethane (CHBr
2
Cl) and Bromoform (CHBr
3
). Since then THMs
have been researched intensively. It is known that the theoretical risk to humans varies
among individual THM species, but the brominated ones are more toxic (U.S. EPA, 1992).
Hence, the formation of brominated THMs during the disinfection process is of great
concern. It is known that when there is bromide existing in raw water, the active halogen
shifts from chlorine to bromine (Rook and Gras, 1978), which means that the reactions
incorporating bromine into natural organic matters (NOM) are faster than those
incorporating chlorine (Symons et al., 1993). Hence the potential for forming Br-THMs is
higher if bromide exists. Studies indicate that Br-THMs could be produced even at a
considerably low concentration of bromide relative to chloride concentration (Minear and