RESEARCH ARTICLE
Improvement of distance relay zone‐3 security using fault
and breaker opening generated traveling waves
Akbar Sharafi | Majid Sanaye‐Pasand | Peyman Jafarian
School of Electrical and Computer
Engineering, College of Engineering,
University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
Correspondence
Akbar Sharafi, School of Electrical and
Computer Engineering, College of
Engineering, University of Tehran,
Tehran, Iran.
Email: a.sharafi@ut.ac.ir
Funding information
University of Tehran, Grant/Award
Number: 8101064-1-10
Summary
This paper presents a new algorithm for discrimination of short‐circuit faults
from power system stressed conditions. The proposed algorithm is based on
the combination of distance relay zone‐3 operation and traveling waves gener-
ated by either the fault or circuit‐breaker switching. By pick‐up of the distance
relay zone‐3, the algorithm looks for traveling waves arriving from the fault
point in the first stage. If a fault generated traveling wave is detected, it would
be concluded that a fault has occurred. Otherwise, the algorithm enters the next
stage and waits for arriving traveling waves caused by open‐switching of the
faulted line remote circuit‐breaker. If any traveling wave is detected, the system
is under fault condition. Otherwise, the reason of zone‐3 pick‐up is due to a
stressed condition. Training a decision tree‐based classifier with the proposed fea-
tures and simulating the method demonstrate that the proposed algorithm is able
to provide a reliable remote back‐up scheme for protection of transmission lines.
KEYWORDS
back‐up protection, circuit‐breaker switching, decision tree, stressed condition, traveling wave
1 | INTRODUCTION
Selective operation of protection system plays a significant
role on the stability of power system. Maloperation of
protective relays has been one of the main contributors to
degradation of power system security in most of wide area
disturbances throughout the world. Spurious operation
of back‐up protective relays due to misinterpretation of
stressed system conditions such as power swing, heavy
loading, and voltage instability as a fault event has been
the cause of many large‐scale blackouts worldwide.
1,2
One of the widely used protection techniques for
transmission lines is distance relaying which operates
based on the impedance between the fault point and the
relay location estimated using local voltage and current
waveforms. Commonly, zone‐3 of a distance relay is used
to provide remote back‐up protection during failure of the
primary protection at the next substation and is typically
set to cover approximately 120% of the longest following
line. One of the advantages of the zone‐3‐based back‐up
protection scheme is that it is completely based on local
measurements, and hence, its performance is not depen-
dent upon the communication system. Because the reach
of zone‐3 might be extended close to the transmission line
load limit to consider in‐feed effects, during stressed con-
ditions such as power swing, load encroachment, and
voltage instability, the impedance trajectory might enter
Symbols: Z
c
, Line surge impedance; R
f
, Fault resistance; V
f
,
Instantaneous magnitude of the voltage at the fault moment; k, Portion
of TW which passes the fault point; n, Sample number; j,
Decomposition level; dj, Detail coefficient of wavelet transform; SE
f
,
Signal energy for fault TWs; Th
f
, Threshold for fault TWs; SE
b
, Signal
energy for breaker opening TWs; Th
b
, Threshold for breaker opening
TWs
Abbreviations: CB, Circuit breaker; DWT, Dyadic wavelet transform;
GPS, Global positioning system; PMUs, Phasor measurement units;
PSB, Power swing blocking; SE, Signal energy; TWs, Traveling‐waves
Received: 5 December 2016 Revised: 5 April 2017 Accepted: 14 July 2017
DOI: 10.1002/etep.2414
Int Trans Electr Energ Syst. 2017;e2414.
https://doi.org/10.1002/etep.2414
Copyright © 2017 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/etep 1 of 12