Quality of Service Performance of the Best-M
OFDMA Feedback Strategy
Hani H. Alyazidi
Florida Institute of Technology
Florida, USA
halyazid2006@my.fit.edu
Ivica Kostanic
Florida Institute of Technology
Florida, USA
kostanic@fit.edu
Abstract— Quality of Service (QoS) is an important perfor-
mance indicator for any technique intended for its inclusion
in commercial systems, as the provided service must fulfil the
customers minimum demands. Several indicators for QoS are
available in the literature, where the Symbol Error Rate (SER)
outstands as one of the most important ones due to its large
relations to correct symbols detection as well as to the achieved
throughput. The Best-M feedback scheme has been proposed as
an interesting technique for its use in Orthogonal Frequency
Division Multiple Access (OFDMA) systems, mainly because of
its data rate and feedback performance. This paper will study
its QoS performance providing the SER closed form expressions
to indicate the effect of the number of users, the operating SNR
and/or the available number of feedback bits on the offered QoS.
The performance of the proposed scheme is also presented via
computer simulations where interesting conclusions are obtained.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA)
[1] is the main multiple access technology in current and future
broadband wireless systems, mainly thanks to its capability to
deal with the frequency selective wireless channel through its
conversion into a set of flat fading subchannels (subC) that are
easily equalized. Within OFDMA each user will be allocated a
bundle of subCs to achieve its demanded rate and throughput
requirements [1].
In order to enhance the system performance and to obtain
the promised figures in the 3GPP Long Term Evolution (LTE)
cellular systems [2], the transmitter must adapt its processing
to the channel characteristics before transmitting, so that the
Channel State Information at the Transmitter side (CSIT) [3]
is required. Feedback is the tool to obtain these characteristics
at the transmitter side, but its benefits are questioned by the
system resources that are employed to carry the feedback
information to the transmitter side. Therefore, a tradeoff has
always been envisaged between the feedback advantages and
its consumed resources [3]. Partial CSIT [3] seems to be a
suitable option to stand on a feasible point within the tradeoff,
nevertheless, the feedback over each one of the subCs is
definitely non feasible and some solution is required.
Based on the large amount of required feedback, some
proposals targeted random users and subCs selection [4], while
others developed a single bit feedback to indicate an ON-OFF
state over all the subCs [5]. In [6], each user is allowed to
feedback over one subC, the one showing the highest Signal-
to-Noise-Ratio (SNR), thus largely decreasing the feedback
load, but then the achieved data rate is far from maximum
achievable one. In recent standardization activities of the 3GPP
for the LTE technology [2] [7], the option of Best-M scheme
[8] is recommended, where each user is asked to feedback the
M subCs showing largest SNR values.
The heterogeneity of applications in the current and future
telecommunication system necessitates characterization of the
QoS, in terms of several metrics based on the required de-
sign. These metrics can be interpreted by minimum required
rate and maximum tolerable SER for the reception quality,
among others. This paper tackles the aforementioned QoS for
the Best-M scheme, where the serviced user has strict QoS
demands in terms of its reception SER.
In order to characterize all the involved parameters in the
Best-M scheme, this paper obtains the closed form expressions
for its SER and data rate. Therefore, the Best-M scheme can
be easily optimized by any commercial operator and/or man-
ufacturer to account for each operating scenario conditions.
Furthermore, with both the SER and data rate expressions,
the system throughput [9] is also obtained. Thanks to the
mathematical formulated expressions, interesting results are
obtained about the impact of the number of available users,
the average SNR and the allowed feedback load.
The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: while
section II deals with the system model, together with two
subsections related to the user opportunistic scheduling and the
Adaptive Coding and Modulation (ACM) used in LTE. Section
III presents the Best-M technique together with its QoS perfor-
mance in 3GPP LTE systems through the data rate, SER and
throughput metrics, and in closed form expressions with all the
involved parameters. Section IV shows the numerical results
and simulations to check for the mathematically formulated
results. The paper finally draws the conclusions in section V.
II. SYSTEM MODEL
A wireless broadband downlink communication system is
considered in this paper, where the total bandwidth is equally
partitioned into S subcarriers or subchannels (subC) through
the OFDMA technology. A total of N single antenna users
are available in the system and asking for service from the
978-1-4673-5307-6/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE 978-1-4673-5307-6/13/$31.00 ©2013 IEEE
The 3rd International Conference on Communications and Information Technology (ICCIT-2013): Wireless Communications and
Signal Processing, Beirut
The 3rd International Conference on Communications and Information Technology (ICCIT-2013): Wireless Communications and
Signal Processing, Beirut
396