Diferentiation of initial skills in 1
st
grade
and the relative age efect in 3
rd
grade
Krzysztof Konarzewski
Educational Research Institute*
Te paper aims to verify two hypotheses. Te frst states that the diferentiation of initial 1
st
grade pupil
skills is negatively correlated with age at entry to school. Tis was tested according to fndings from the
ERI study Six and seven year olds at the start of school. Te variation of reading and writing scores of
1164 pupils aged 5.9–7.9 years who were beginning 1
st
grade decreased in subsequent age quartiles. Te
second hypothesis – that classroom diferentiation of pupils’ initial skills in 1
st
grade is positively correla-
ted with the birthdate efect in 3
rd
grade – was tested on data of 4838 pupils from 254 classrooms drawn
from the 2011 PIRLS and TIMSS studies in Poland. Skills were evaluated on the basis of parental reports.
Hierarchical linear analysis (gender, SES and school location controlled) showed that the greater the dif-
ferentiation of language skills in 1
st
grade, the greater the birthdate efect in mathematics in 3
rd
grade. Tis
result suggests that school entry age is of lesser importance than the methods used to reduce diferences
in children’s school readiness at the onset of education.
Keywords: education; school readiness; birthdate efect; PIRLS; TIMSS; HLM.
©
Educational Research Institute
Edukacja 2017, 2(141), 100–112
doi: 10.24131/3724.170206
issn: 0239-6858
*
Address: ul. Górczewska 8, 01-180 Warszawa, Poland.
E-mail: konarzewski@neostrada.pl
it is indistinguishable from zero. The differ-
ences in achievement of girls and boys tend
to diminish i n a similar way. The average
age of pupils in the class depends on legal
regulations and social standards. For this
reason, the interaction can be detected only
in international data.
Any explanation of this interaction
must be embedded in the time perspec-
tive. Many studies show that the difference
between achievement of older and younger
pupils in a class (referred to as the relative
age effect) decreases in consecutive years
of education (DiPasquale, Moule and Fle-
welling, 1980; Dolata and Pokropek, 2012;
Hutchison and Sharp, 1999, after: Sharp,
2002; Jones and Mandeville, 1990; Lan-
ger, Kalk and Searls, 1984; Verachtert, De
T
he aim of this article is to explain an
intriguing phenomenon: a small but
statistically significant part of scholastic
achievement of ten-year-old pupils from
25 European countries is dependent on the
interaction of the relative and absolute age of
pupils (Konarzewski, 2013). The interaction
is illustrated in Figure 1. Individual points
represent average mathematics achievement
of children divided into groups by three cri-
teria: average age at school entry (6.2, 6.6, and
7.1 years), relative age in the class (younger,
middle-aged, older) and gender. We can see
that the achievement of the oldest pupils
in their classes is higher than the youngest
pupils, and this difference is the greatest in
early-start classes, while in late-start classes,