Theoretical Investigation of the Dihydrogen Bond Linking MH
2
with HCCRgF (M ) Zn,
Cd; Rg ) Ar, Kr)
Mohammad Solimannejad*
Quantum Chemistry Group, Department of Chemistry, Arak UniVersity, 38156-879 Arak, Iran
Steve Scheiner
Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, Utah State UniVersity, Logan, Utah 84322-0300
ReceiVed: NoVember 3, 2005
An ab initio computational study of the properties of four linear dihydrogen-bonded complexes pairing MH
2
(M d Zn, Cd) with HCCRgF (Rg d Ar, Kr) was undertaken at the MP2/DGDZVP level of theory. The
calculated complexation energies of the linear complexes vary between 6.5 kJ/mol for M d Zn to 8.5 kJ/mol
for M d Cd. Equilibrium interatomic H‚‚‚H distances are roughly 2.07 Å for all four complexes. The red
shifts of the H-C stretching frequency of HCCRgF correlate nicely with the interaction energies.
1. Introduction
The subject of dihydrogen bonds has received a great deal
of attention lately.
1-6
The dihydrogen bond is an attractive H‚‚‚H
interaction, arising from the close approach of a protonic H atom
and a hydridic H atom.
7
In a parallel vein, metal hydrides are
of considerable importance in chemical synthesis as intermedi-
ates in catalytic hydrogenation reactions. Transition-metal atoms
react with dihydrogen to produce metal dihydrides or dihydrogen
complexes, and these may be trapped in solid matrix samples
for infrared spectroscopic study.
8
It has been shown previously that metal hydrides are capable
of forming dihydrogen bonds.
9-12
Recently, we have published
a series of papers concerning dihydrogen-bonded complexes of
metal hydrides with certain rare gas derivatives.
13-15
We turn
our attention now to the potential interactions involving the
alkynic H of rare-gas systems HC≡CRgF. In the absence of an
experimental search for the title complexes up to the present, a
theoretical analysis of their properties would appear to be in
order. The present work thus reports a detailed examination of
the stabilities, electronic structure, and vibrational frequencies
of the title complexes for the first time.
2. Computational Details
Calculations were performed using the Gaussian03 system
of codes.
16
Geometry optimizations and frequency calculations
were performed at the MP2 level using DGDZVP basis set.
17
Harmonic vibrational frequency calculations were performed,
which confirm the predicted structures as minima in the potential
energy surfaces (PESs) of the title complexes The charge
distribution has been analyzed by the natural bond orbital
(NBO)
18
partitioning scheme at the MP2/DGDZVP level. The
counterpoise (CP) method
19
was used to correct basis set
superposition error (BSSE) in the calculation of the binding
energy.
3. Results and Discussion
Association of the linear HCCRgF molecules (Rg d Ar, Kr)
with linear MH
2
(M d Zn, Cd) subunits
8
leads to the similarly
linear C
∞V
complexes HMH‚‚‚HCCRgF, which were calculated
to be minima at the MP2/DGDZVP level of theory. Completely
optimized geometries for all species are reported in Figure 1.
The computed complexation energies of the linear di-
hydrogen-bonded complexes are about 6.5 kJ/mol for the Zn
complexes, as compared to the larger 8.5 kJ/mol for those that
contain Cd, as indicated in Table 1. The nature of the rare gas
atom has little effect on this quantity, although there is a slight
preference for Kr over Ar. This 0.3 kJ/mol difference, however,
is probably within the margin of error of the computational
method.While quantitatively different, the interaction energies
computed without BSSE correction obey the same trends.
The NBO atomic charges displayed in Figure 1 reveal
relatively minor changes upon complexation. The process seems
to make the “hydridic” H of the HMH, that is, the bridging
proton, somewhat more negative by an amount of about 0.05.
* Author to whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:
m-solimannejad@araku.ac.ir.
Figure 1. MP2/DGDZVP geometries (Å) and NBO atomic charges
(e) of HMH‚‚‚HCCRgF complexes. Results for monomers in italics.
11933 J. Phys. Chem. A 2005, 109, 11933-11935
10.1021/jp0563383 CCC: $30.25 © 2005 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 12/03/2005