© 2010 Plant Management Network.
Accepted for publication 2 September 2010. Published 22 October 2010.
Assessing Bt Silage Corn in Maine
John Jemison, Extension Professor, University of Maine Cooperative
Extension, Orono, Maine, ME 04469; and Chris Reberg-Horton,
Assistant Professor, Department of Crop Science, North Carolina
State University, Raleigh, NC 27695
Corresponding author: John Jemison. jemison@maine.edu
Jemison, J., and Reberg-Horton, C. 2010. Assessing Bt silage corn in Maine. Online. Crop
Management doi:10.1094/CM-2010-1022-01-RS.
Abstract
Over 90 percent of the corn grown in Maine is grown for silage, yet most research
has focused on the effectiveness of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) corn as grain corn.
In response to grower interest, a seven site-year-location (SYL) study was
conducted across the dairy production region of Maine to evaluate the effect of Bt
corn on insect feeding damage, silage corn yield, mycotoxin content in chopped
silage, and forage quality. Black cutworm damage over the course of the study
was generally less than 1%, and European corn borer (ECB) damage was light to
moderate with stalk tunneling between 2% for Bt hybrids and 11% based on non-
Bt hybrids. Although Bt significantly reduced ECB feeding in leaves and stalks, this
did not lead to yield, silage mycotoxin, or forage quality differences. Based on
these results, potential yield increases and reduced mycotoxins in silage would be
expected only in years with greater insect pressure than that found in this study.
Introduction
Several types of transgenic silage and grain corn hybrids that express
Bacillus thurin g iensis (Bt) insecticidal proteins have been used in the USA in
most states since 1996; Maine approved their use in 2006. The primary Maine
pests that Bt proteins are used to control include European corn borer ( Ostrinia
nubilalis ), black cutworm ( Agrotis ipsilon ), and to a lesser extent corn
rootworm ( Diabrotica sp). In previously published research, corn yield was
influenced primarily by intensity of insect pest pressure, environmental
conditions, and crop rotation p atterns (7,12,13). While most research has shown
Bt corn to be economically effective with grain corn under moderate to high p est
pressure (4,6,7,10), less research has been conducted evaluating the
effectiveness of Bt corn grown for silage corn. Over 90 percent of the corn
grown in Maine (and much of northern New England) is grown for silage, and
combined with hay it makes up the primary feed source for dairy cattle ( Bos
taurus L.).
European corn borer (ECB) overwinters in Maine. The intensity of pest
pressure and the amount of damage to yield and quality from larvae tunneling
in the stalk or feeding in leaf tissue varies from year to year (1). Leaf holes and
stalk tunneling may also allow plant pathogen entry, possibly leading to
mycotoxin concentrations toxic to cows (8,17).
Black cutworm (BCW) does not overwinter in Maine; adults moths move
into Maine on storms from the south. For this reason, BCW pressure is variable
from year to year, but damage can be sufficiently high to force growers to
replant fields. While northern corn root worms Diabrotica barbari (NCR) and
western corn rootworm ( Diabrotica virgifera virgifera ) (WCR) are found in
Maine, the weaker and less damaging NCR is much more common. Damage is
generally less than that found in the mid-Atlantic or midwestern states (9,15).
Grower decisions to adopt Bt corn are based on seed cost, yield benefit, and
forage quality compared to non-Bt hybrid lines (2). No studies on the
effectiveness of Bt corn in silage systems have been produced from the New
En gland region. Based on grower interest, seven exp eriments were conducted in
the dairy production region of Maine from 2006 through 2009 to evaluate Bt
corn hybrids and their near isolines for plant damage, yield, quality, and
mycotoxin content.
22 October 2010 Crop Management