Corresponding Author: Nor Asmahani Ibrahim, Faculty of Business and Management, Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin,
Terengganu, Malaysia Email: nora_asmahani@yahoo.com
7
International Journal of Business and Management 6 (1): 07-12, 2022
e-ISSN: 2590-3721
© RMP Publications, 2022
DOI: 10.26666/rmp.ijbm.2022.1.2
The Role of Propinquity and Coordination in Influencing Competitive Advantage of
Retail SMEs in Malaysia
Nor Asmahani Ibrahim
1
, Rosmimah Roslin
2
and Rozita Naina Mohamed
2
1
Faculty of Business and Management, Universiti Sultan Zainal Abidin, Terengganu,
Malaysia,
2
Faculty of Business and Management, Universiti Teknologi Mara, Shah Alam, Selangor,
Malaysia,
Abstract: The existence of hypermarkets and supermarkets with modern retail format has affected the
performance of many retailers in the category of small medium enterprises (SMEs) in Malaysia. In this era
of disruptive marketing, the main challenges of retail SMEs are the ability to survive, to remain competitive
and to sustain the business. With the challenges of finding the right strategies to compete effectively, there
is now an inclination to look at social networks as means of establishing strong market presence. Engaging
and maintaining social networks in their business relationships is essential for retail SMEs if they want to
address strategic positions and subsequently build strong competitive advantage in the business. This study
postulates that establishing social networks, specifically in terms of propinquity (related with network
cluster, network centrality and geographic proximity) among social network members, will enable the
gathering of important resources needed by retail SMEs to secure more sustainable competitive advantage.
However, only few studies have focused on social networks especially from the Asian context and many
have overlooked the importance of social networks in retailing. This study also suggests the need to focus
on coordination in relation to propinquity of social networks which refers to the location of retail SMEs and
their ability to coordinate efforts to gain competitive advantage. This study extends the literature on social
networks by providing a conceptual framework describing the importance of propinquity on coordination
of activities leading to the development of competitive advantage for retail SMEs.
Key words: Social networks, Propinquity, Retail SMEs, Coordination, Competitive advantage
INTRODUCTION
For many countries, small-medium enterprises
(SMEs) are the largest contributor of economic,
political and social development. In Malaysia, the
growth of retail SMEs can be seen through customer
demands leading to the rise of revenue for the retail
industry whilst there are diversity of retail formats
such as hypermarkets, supermarkets and modern
grocery stores from the year 1990 onwards [1].
Under the National Key Economic Areas (NKEA),
retail and wholesale also provide the foundation to
maximize contribution to the Gross National Income
(GNI) of the country with the estimation of income
around RM156 billion and providing a total of
454,190 new jobs by 2020[2]. It is on this note that
many countries rely on the development of SMEs
because of their significant contribution in assisting
the country’s economic growth, social uplifting and
political stability [3][4].
The Malaysian government has also placed much
emphasis in facilitating the development of small
businesses including the retail SMEs in order to
ensure their sustainability and continued
contribution to the country’s socio-economic
development. In line with the attention given by
government, many programs have been developed
by numerous government agencies to provide
training, financial support and other relevant
incentives to assist and monitor the development of
SMEs in Malaysia. Despite many facilitating
programs and funding given by the government,
there are still daunting challenges faced by the SMEs
in Malaysia. In retailing specifically, performance
has decreased in 2015 (8.1%) compared to 2014
(11.1%). While in 2016, there was a slight increase