MIKHAIL YU. TREISTER
NORTH SYRIAN METALWORKERS IN ARCHAIC GREEK
SETTLEMENTS?
Summary The Syrian origin ofa casting mouldfor jewellery found at Al Mina
leads to a discussion of similar moulds of the same origin, including examples
from East Greek sites, and of the jewellery types produced. The presence of
Syrian craftsman adds force to arguments for the importance of Syrian products
and workmanship in Greek orientalising art.
In the 1930s Sir Leonard Woolley explored
the area of the mouth of the River Orontes in
North Syria and excavated a settlement at Al
Mina which yielded a remarkable quantity of
Greek Geometric pottery. The excavation
reports were published in a moderately detailed
manner, with the objects other than pottery
summarily (Woolley 1938; 1959, 172-188;
Boardman 1980, 38-54; 1990a, 169-190;
Riis 1982,244-251, n. 16-S. 244; Graham
1986). The pottery finds, Greek, Cypriot and
Syrian were studied more intensively (Beazley
1939; Robertson 1940; Smith 1942; Boardman
1957; 1959; du Plat Taylor 1959; Coldstream
1968,310-316; Riis 1970, 137 ff.; Gjerstad
1974: Popham, Hatcher, Pollard 1980;
Popham, Pollard, Hatcher 1983). Less
attention was paid to the finds other than
pottery (Boardman 1990b, 11, 15, N 121;
Francis, Vickers 1983).
W. R6llig has recently stated that the role
of Al Mina, whose actual character is unknown
despite being called a 'Greek emporion, Greek
commercial or trading town, Greek outpost,
centre of Greek commercial activities' has been
much over-rated (R611ig 1992, 95). The point
of view reflects a tendency in modern
scholarship to revise the earlier suggested
important role of Al Mina in Greek-Oriental
contacts (Niemeyer 1984, 27). Perhaps the
most clear expression of this is found in A.J.
Graham's view that the finds and architecture
of Al Mina clearly attest, not a Greek city, but
a Levantine settlement, probably founded by
Phoenicians. The author considers that Al
Mina was just one of many places in the
Eastern Mediterranean where Greeks made
contact with the Orient. 'It should be
recognized, therefore, that there is little left
of the interpretation which made Al Mina a
uniquely early Greek colony in the East, and
a uniquely important place for contacts
between Greece and the Orient' (Graham
1986). J. Boardman (1990a, 171) has stated
that his attempt to evaluate the probable role
of Al Mina in the 'orientalising revolution' 'is
bedevilled by the incomplete publication of the
finds at Al Mina'. Therefore, the publication
of the casting mould from 1937 excavations
at Al Mina, I is significant for ethnic
OXFORD JOURNAL OF ARCHAEOLOGY
© Blackwell Publishers Ltd. 1995, 108 Cowley Road, Oxford OX4 UF, UK
and 238 Main Street, Cambridge, MA 02142, USA. 159