Research Article
Complementary contribution of parents and therapists in
the assessment process of children
Limor Rosenberg,
1
Orit Bart,
1
Navah Z. Ratzon
1
and Tal Jarus
2
1
Department of Occupational Therapy, School of Health Professions, Sackler Faculty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University,
Tel Aviv, Israel and
2
Department of Occupational Science and Occupational Therapy, CanDo Research Center, Faculty of
Medicine, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Background/aim: Traditional developmental models assume
that the underlying capacities of children contribute to
their participation. In this framework, preschoolers who
are referred for occupational therapy services usually
undergo an assessment intended to identify capacities in
certain domains. Contrary to this, newer ecological models
assume that child participation is a consequence of a mul-
tidimensional interaction between personal and environ-
mental factors. As a result clinicians are increasingly
focusing their assessment on performance and participa-
tion. This study aimed to assess the correlation between
children’s performance skills, their capacities and partici-
pation; and to explore whether parents’ observations,
alongside therapist observations and standardised assess-
ments, contribute to an enhanced understanding of child
participation.
Method: Participants included 188 parents and their chil-
dren, aged 4–6 years, with and without mild developmen-
tal difficulties. Data were collected using standardised
assessments for child capacities, and questionnaires com-
pleted by parents and occupational therapists regarding
child participation and performance skills.
Results: Significant correlations were found between par-
ent assessments of child performance skills and child par-
ticipation, but not with child capacities. The opposite was
found to be true for occupational therapist assessments of
child performance skills which were found to correlate
with child capacities, but not with participation. Addition-
ally, an interaction effect was found for both groups.
Occupational therapists reported higher performance skills
as compared to parents, but the difference was only signif-
icant for children without mild difficulties.
Conclusion: As suggested by ecological models of child
participation, the findings highlight the importance of par-
ent-therapist collaboration in the assessment process of
children.
KEY WORDS assessment, child’s participation, func-
tional performance, performance skills.
Introduction
Changing assessment approaches
Preschoolers who are referred for occupational therapy
usually undergo an individual assessment comprised of
various standardised developmental tests and con-
ducted in a formal setting by a trained occupational
therapist. These tests are intended to identify strengths
or difficulties in certain developmental domains such as
sensory – processing, gross and fine motor abilities, or
visual – motor integration. The predominant use of
these tests is based on hierarchical developmental mod-
els which assume that the underlying capacities of the
child contribute to his or her participation, where
decreased capacities limit participation (Rodger et al.,
2003).
However, a shift from hierarchical to ecological mod-
els of disability and health suggests that the child’s
functional performance is a consequence of a multidi-
mensional interaction between various developmental
and environmental factors (Simeonsson et al., 2003).
This shift has triggered clinicians to question the ecolog-
ical validity of traditionally used tests and to integrate
functional assessments into their practice (Majnemer,
2009). Based on ecological models of health which have
emerged over the past decade (such as the International
Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health
Limor Rosenberg PhD; Occupational Therapist. Orit Bart
PhD; Occupational Therapist. Navah Z. Ratzon PhD; Occu-
pational Therapist. Tal Jarus PhD; Occupational Therapist.
Correspondence: Limor Rosenberg, Department of Occupa-
tional Therapy, School of Health Professions, Sackler Fac-
ulty of Medicine, Tel Aviv University, Ramat Aviv, Tel
Aviv 69978, Israel. Email: Limbo@bezeqint.net
Accepted for publication 9 March 2013.
© 2013 The Authors
Australian Occupational Therapy Journal © 2013 Occupational
Therapy Australia
Australian Occupational Therapy Journal (2013) 60, 410–415 doi: 10.1111/1440-1630.12041