Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
NDT and E International
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/ndteint
A microwave non-destructive testing method for controlling polymeric
coating of metal layers in industrial products
A. Mazzinghi, A. Freni, L. Capineri
∗
DINFO, University of Florence, Via di Santa Marta 3, 50139, Florence, Italy
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Inspection systems
Sensor
Sizing
Thickness
Non-destructive testing
Microwave sensing
Periodic structures
Oil industry
Metal-plastic composites
ABSTRACT
The paper exploits the possibility of extracting the geometric properties of a polymeric coating of periodic metal
layers used in industrial products from non-contact microwave backscattering measurements. Specifically, a
flexible pipe having a periodically corrugated metal profile coated with a thick Polivinylidenedifluoride (PVDF)
layer, suitable for oil industry applications, has been considered. The combined use of magnitude and phase of
the reflected signal, acquired on a wide relative frequency band (∼15%), allows calculating the dielectric filling
level and the period of each corrugation with accuracy better than 1/100 of the period length, 21 mm in our
case. The results of an experimental campaign, carried out to estimate the accuracy achievable in the operational
environment, are also shown.
1. Introduction
Several industrial manufacturing processes of costly and high re-
liability items involve the use of different materials. In general, such
materials are combined to form a composite structure with dimensional
and structural mechanical characteristics that must accomplish to tight
standards for acceptability. Examples are composite structures made of
metallic parts coated by polymeric layers. The coating, made of che-
mically inert polymers, ensures protection against corrosion, while the
metal structures ensure the mechanical resilience. Depending on the
application, the metal layer can be flat or corrugated. In the latter case,
the right adhesion and filling between the metal and the polymer
coating can be lost, due to the variability of the manufacturing process.
In the future perspective of the digital industrial manufacturing for
optimizing the production costs [1], and for reducing the time to
market, it is important to develop sensor systems that can provide real
time measurements of those parameters useful to control the manu-
facturing process.
In this work, we have investigated non-destructive testing methods
suitable for the analysis of the adhesion quality of a polymeric layer,
with up to 20 mm thickness, deposited on a periodic metallic frame-
work. The polymeric coating can be obtained with an extrusion process.
As a reference example, we have considered a flexible pipe for gas or oil
industry [2] as that shown in Fig. 1. In this case, to guarantee the
flexibility of the pipe, the polymeric coating has not to fill the grooves
in the interlocking profile (Fig. 1b top). In particular, when an air gap
between the coating and the metallic corrugations is less than 0.5 mm
then the polymeric coating is considered out of the specifications (see
Fig. 1b bottom).
An initial evaluation of common methods used for non-destructive
investigation has been carried out taking in mind that the system has to
be as simple as possible, real-time, and with no contact with the pipe. In
fact, it will be manufactured in harsh environment and subjected to
vibrations. The outcomes are reported in the following. Basically, there
are two techniques suitable for the detection of anomalous polymer
coating profile: electromagnetic methods related to the electrical im-
pedance variations, and ultrasonic methods related to the acoustic
impedance variations. The feasibility of the ultrasonic methods was
here first considered, since the transducers and electronic front-end can
be easily purchased with COTS (Commercial Off-the-Shelf compo-
nents).
The bottom profile of the polymer coating can be in principle
measured by ultrasonic methods with high spatial resolution probes
operating at high central frequency [3]. A series of preliminary tests
with several contact probes, with operating frequency from 0.5 MHz to
10 MHz, placed over a layer of Teflon or PVDF, with thickness from
12 mm to 20 mm, has pointed out a very high attenuation, which is
estimated around 20 dB/cm. The limited propagation velocity of the
polymer coating (between 1700 m/s and 2200 m/s) allows enough axial
resolution when operating at 1.5 MHz in pulse echo mode (λ
u
/
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ndteint.2018.12.003
Received 13 August 2018; Received in revised form 16 November 2018; Accepted 11 December 2018
∗
Corresponding author.
E-mail addresses: agnese.mazzinghi@unifi.it (A. Mazzinghi), freni@unifi.it (A. Freni), lorenzo.capineri@unifi.it (L. Capineri).
NDT and E International 102 (2019) 207–217
Available online 15 December 2018
0963-8695/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T