Research
Reprinted from AJGP Vol. 52, No. 8, August 2023 567 © The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners 2023
Pattern of mental health attendances
at a metropolitan university general
practice clinic in Sydney before and
during the COVID-19 pandemic
Vivien Nguyen, Tim Tse, Simon Willcock,
Sanjyot Vagholkar, Bosco Wu
Background and objective
The aim of this study was to describe the pattern of
mental health attendances in a university-based general
practice clinic during phases of the COVID-19 pandemic.
The COVID-19 pandemic has created social and medical
disruptions to the Australian community. There is a
literature gap pertaining to the ongoing trends that
extend beyond the initial ‘first wave’ of the pandemic
in the context of the Australian landscape.
Methods
Retrospective data were obtained from 435 adults
attending a community university-based general practice
in Sydney, Australia, during four time periods: T1, before
the COVID-19 pandemic (1 February – 7 March 2019);
T2, during the first COVID-19 lockdown (31 March –
4 May 2020); T3, during the second COVID-19 lockdown
(20 August – 23 September 2021); and T4, after the end
of the COVID-19 lockdowns (1 February – 7 March 2022).
Attendances were identified as mental health Medicare
Benefits Schedule codes for face-to-face, televideo and
telephone consultations. Patterns of attendances were
evaluated using frequency analysis.
Results
There was a decline in mental health attendances
compared to all attendances at the general practice
from T1 (7.5%) to T2 (4.8%). During T4, mental health
attendances returned to 7.1% of all consultations at the
general practice. Face-to-face attendances decreased by
50% in T2 relative to T1, and this trend was maintained
in T3 and T4, whereas the utilisation of telehealth
approached that of face-to-face by T4.
Discussion
Post-pandemic policies that support the use of telehealth
in general practice may help improve mental healthcare
delivery and outcomes.
THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC has created uncertainty around work,
safety and financial security, thereby impacting the mental health
of the Australian community.
1–6
By 30 March 2020, the Australian
Government expanded Medicare-funded telehealth items to all
Australians in response to the pandemic.
7
Although there were initial
declines in healthcare activities across New South Wales (NSW),
an analysis of the ‘40 weeks of the pandemic year’ (January 2020 –
October 2020) reported an increase in the number of mental health
Medicare Benefits Schedule (MBS) services provided, supporting the
significant mental health burden as a consequence of COVID-19.
8,9
In March 2020, there was a 30% drop in face-to-face consultations
and a rise in telehealth consultations across Australia.
10
For example,
a time series study of attendances at a regional Victorian Aboriginal
Community Controlled Health Organisation saw a 27% increase in
all attendances from March to June 2020, suggesting that telehealth
availability allowed greater accessibility to medical services.
11
Another
study of changes due to telehealth use during the pandemic (to May
2020) found that women were generally higher users of health services
and that this gender gap was greater for telehealth,
12
calling for an
evaluation into factors contributing to this divide. There is also a
literature gap pertaining to the ongoing trends in modes of healthcare
delivery that extend past the initial ‘first wave’ of COVID-19 in
Australia (March – September 2020).
Given primary care’s frontline role in healthcare delivery and the
rising mental health burden from COVID-19 restrictions, the aim of
this study was to observe patterns in mental health attendances in a
university-based community general practice in periods before, during
and after the COVID-19 pandemic, specifically the distribution of
face-to-face, telephone and televideo attendances. A secondary aim
of the study was to explore the effects of age, ethnicity, birth sex and
student status on presentation patterns. Given the temporary telehealth
extension by the Australian Government in early 2022, the findings
of this study will provide data for policy makers to consider the
continuation and expansion of telehealth subsidisation.
Methods
Study design, population and settings
Retrospective data were obtained from patients attending a
university-based community mixed-billing general practice in Sydney