Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Nuclear Engineering and Design
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/nucengdes
Stability analysis of the Supercritical Water Reactor by means of the root
locus criterion
E. Cervi, A. Cammi
⁎
Politecnico di Milano, Department of Energy, Nuclear Engineering Division, via La Masa 34, 20156 Milano, Italy
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Supercritical
Density wave oscillations
Stability analysis
Root locus
Thermal-hydraulics
Neutronics
SCWR
Nuclear reactors
ABSTRACT
The Supercritical Water Reactor (SCWR) is a concept for an advanced nuclear reactor operating at high tem-
perature (500 °C average core outlet temperature at nominal power) and at high pressure (25 MPa), which give
the SCWR a thermal efficiency of about 45%. However, due to the strong variability of the water properties near
the thermodynamic pseudocritical point, concerns are raised towards thermal-hydraulic instabilities. A simu-
lation tool was developed in Matlab® from the perspective of linear systems, aimed at investigating the reactor
stability and identifying potential regions of instability through a consolidated and relatively simple approach. A
frequency-domain stability analysis of the SCWR is carried out with the root locus criterion, characterizing the
system stability features over its entire operating power interval. The impact of the coolant flow rate on the
stability is also studied. The results show that the system is stable over the whole investigated operational range.
Finally, the dynamic behavior of the SCWR is compared to the Boiling Water Reactor (BWR), pointing out
significant differences due to the different working points and design features of the two reactors. The results of
this study could be a starting point for further research on the SCWR, providing the designers with important
feedbacks for the optimization of the SCWR coolant circuit.
1. Introduction
The Supercritical Water Reactor (SCWR) is one of the six concepts
under investigation in the GEN-IV international advanced reactor de-
velopment program. It is a combination between the traditional Light
Water Reactor (LWR) and the supercritical Fossil Power Plant (FPP).
Water at a pressure and at a temperature above its critical point
(p
c
= 22.06 MPa, T
c
= 373.9 °C) is called supercritical. The technology
of supercritical water used as coolant is well established in the field of
Fossil Power Plants, allowing to reach a larger thermal efficiency due to
the increased pressure and temperature of the fluid.
Since no boiling takes place in the SCWR, the reactor can be oper-
ated at high temperature without any concern about the CHF (critical
heat flux), which limits the operating temperature of the operating
temperature of the traditional LWRs. For this reason, the system reaches
a thermal efficiency of about 45%, significantly higher than the current
LWRs and comparable to those of modern Fossil Power Plants (Ortega
Gómez, 2009). Moreover, compared to a Boiling Water Reactor, steam
separators and recirculation pumps are no longer needed, allowing
significant plant simplifications and a more compact design.
One of the major concerns about the SCWR is represented by
thermal-hydraulic instabilities, due to the strong variability of the water
density near the thermodynamic pseudocritical point. In fact, owing to
the large temperature difference between the core inlet and outlet, the
water density decrease in the SCWR core is even larger than in BWRs.
Hence, even if no phase transition takes place, all the instability phe-
nomena occurring in two-phase flows can also be observed in the
SCWR.
So far, the problem of thermal-hydraulic instabilities in supercritical
water reactors has been addressed by many authors. Chatoorgoon
(2001) studied the stability of a supercritical fluid flow in a natural
circulation CANDU-X supercritical reactor (Dimmick et al., 1998) using
a non-linear numerical code. Yi et al. (2004) developed a linear stability
analysis code in frequency domain to study the thermal-hydraulic sta-
bility of the SCWR-H, a thermal-spectrum supercritical reactor, by
means of the decay ratio. Cheng and Yang (2008) developed a point-
hydraulics model to study the onset of self-sustaining flow oscillations
in a supercritical cooling loop, based on the definition of suited di-
mensionless numbers. Ortega Gómez et al. (2008) studied the linear
stability characteristics of a uniformly heated supercritical channel by
evaluating the eigenvalues of a one-dimensional model. A time-domain
analysis of non-linear phenomena was also presented. Moreover, a
stability analysis of the SCWR, based on the U.S. reference design, was
carried out by Zhao (2005). Further investigations on core-wide
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2018.08.004
Received 23 February 2018; Received in revised form 21 July 2018; Accepted 7 August 2018
⁎
Corresponding author.
E-mail address: antonio.cammi@polimi.it (A. Cammi).
Nuclear Engineering and Design 338 (2018) 137–157
0029-5493/ © 2018 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
T