1 Copyright © 2002 by ASME
Proceedings of OMAE’02
21
st
International Conference on Offshore Mechanics and Arctic Engineering
June 23-28, 2002, Oslo, Norway
OMAE2002-28620
NONLINEAR WAVE DISTURBANCE AROUND A VERTICAL CIRCULAR COLUMN
C.T. Stansberg and H. Braaten
Norwegian Marine Technology Research Institute A/S (MARINTEK)
Trondheim, Norway
ABSTRACT
The wave disturbance close to vertical columns is
analysed. In particular, the deviations from linear predictions
are investigated, by experimental as well as by numerical
methods. Thus a second-order numerical diffraction model is
established by means of a diffraction analysis code (WAMIT)
and compared to model tests with a single, fixed column with
diameter 16m. Tests in regular, bi-chromatic as well as irregular
waves are run. Significant nonlinear effects are observed,
especially in steep waves, with the maximum elevation in front
of the column increasing from 11.5m in a linear prediction to
around 19m , in a 12s regular wave with 22m wave height. The
main nonlinear effects in front of the column are identified as
second-order sum-frequency and difference-frequency terms,
plus a significant nonlinear increase in the first harmonic
component. The WAMIT prediction of the second-order effects
agrees fairly well with the measurements, although with some
overprediction and underprediction, respectively, of the sum-
frequency and difference-frequency (LF and mean set-up)
terms in the steepest waves. For the underprediction of the first
harmonic, however, a theory beyond second order is required.
INTRODUCTION
The wave field disturbance around single and multiple
vertical columns is an essential issue in the prediction of deck
clearances under large-volume offshore platforms. This is a
classical problem, which was solved analytically for a single
bottom-mounted column, assuming linear potential theory, in
the early 1950’s (McCamy and Fuchs, 1954). However,
experience through a number of studies throughout the recent
decade has shown that nonlinear effects may grow siginficant
in steep waves. This includes nonlinearities in the incoming
waves as well as in the wave-structure interaction. Evidence
from experiments is found through a variety of studies on
single columns, such as Kriebel (1992, 1993); Niedzwecki &
Duggal (1992); Stansberg & Nielsen (2001). For a very large
cylinder, some nonlinear effects were also observed in
Sterndorff & Skourup (2001), although a considerable part of
their measurements were reasonably close to linear. For a
multi-leg structure, the experiments in Swan et. al. (1997)
showed particular nonlinear effects. Furthermore, several of the
experimental studies have shown a significant statistical scatter.
Various nonlinear numerical approaches have also been
published, see e.g. Büchmann et.al. (1998), Ferrant (1999),
ISSC (2000).
The leading nonlinear contribution is the second-order
correction from diffraction theory. In the present analysis, a
second-order diffraction-radiation code (WAMIT, 1995) is
applied in a numerical analysis of the single-column problem,
and compared to results from a set of systematic and dedicated
model scale experiments. The experiments have been described
earlier in a ISSC comparative study (ISSC, 2000) and in
Stansberg & Nielsen (2001). The comparative study is further
described in Nielsen (2002). In the following presentation, data
from tests in regular, bi-chromatic as well as irregular waves
are included, with wave elevation measurements made in a grid
of 32 locations near the column. The work is a continuation of
the initial analysis in Stansberg & Nielsen (2001). .A full
second-order numerical analysis is made, including quadratic
transfer functions (QTFs) for sum-frequency as well as for
difference-frequency (set-up / set-down) terms. The purpose of
the work is to observe how well the use of this perturbation
method can describe the measured nonlinearities, and to
provide background material for a discussion on its use in
future design.
NONLINEAR DIFFRACTION: SOME EXAMPLES FROM
MODEL TESTS
Measurements of wave enhancement around a 16m-
diameter vertical column were observed through systematic
model tests and presented in Stansberg & Nielsen (2001).
Linear and second-order diffraction theory was compared to the
measurements, and predicted trends were fairly well
recognized. However, the nonlinearities observed indicate that a
further and more detailed investigation is needed, also
including more of the data, for a satisfactory description of the