TMD-like symptoms elicited by voluntary
low-level jaw clenching.
10
These previous
studies provide highly mixed support for a
possible etiologic or maintenance role for
estrogen in the pathogenesis of TMD.
We undertook a study to further elucidate
the relationship between exogenous estro-
gen use and TMD. We confirmed current
Background. Studies of historical data
suggest a link between exog-
enous estrogen use and
referral for treatment for
temporomandibular dis-
orders, or TMDs. The
purpose of the authors’
study was to determine
the association between
exogenous estrogen use and
signs and symptoms of TMD assessed by
direct physical examination in a randomly
selected community sample of primarily
postmenopausal women.
Methods. A calibrated clinical examiner
examined a stratified random sample of 510
women aged 37 to 82 years using the Cra-
niomandibular Index, or CMI. All medica-
tions that subjects were taking at the time
of the examination were identified by inter-
view and examination of subjects’ medica-
tion containers on two occasions. One hun-
dred seventy-four subjects were taking
medications containing estrogen, and 336
were taking no such medications.
Results. The muscle and joint signs and
symptoms of women taking and not taking
estrogen were not significantly different
after the authors controlled for sociocul-
tural, demographic and health care utiliza-
tion variables. Estrogen use also failed to
distinguish women receiving relatively high
and low scores on the CMI.
Conclusion. Estrogen replacement
therapy does not place women at increased
risk of developing TMDs.
Clinical Implications. Clinicians need
not be concerned that patients taking oral
contraceptives or replacement estrogens
are at increased risk of developing TMDs.
Is use of
exogenous estrogen
associated with
temporomandibular
signs and symptoms?
JOHN P. HATCH, Ph.D.; JOHN D. RUGH, Ph.D.;
SHIRO SAKAI, D.D.S., M.S.; MICHELE J. SAUNDERS,
D.M.D., M.S., M.P.H.
T
he differential prevalence of temporomandib-
ular disorders, or TMDs, in men and women
has long puzzled dental clinicians and re-
searchers. Population-based studies show the
prevalence of TMD to be from about two to
five times higher in women than in men
in community samples.
1-3
The differen-
tial prevalence is even greater in clin-
ical samples.
2
No plausible explanation for the
higher prevalence of TMD in women
has been proposed, but it seems reason-
able to ask whether the sex hormones
may play some role in etiology or main-
tenance of the condition. For instance,
variations in sex hormone levels associ-
ated with the menstrual cycle may mod-
ulate pain perception.
4-7
Also, prescrip-
tion of exogenous estrogen in the form
of estrogen replacement in menopause
or oral contraceptives during reproduc-
tive years may increase the risk of
being referred for TMD care.
8
Exoge-
nous estrogen in the form of oral contra-
ceptives does not affect mean pain
intensity ratings in regularly ovulating
patients with TMD, but it might affect
the pattern or variability of pain rat-
ings.
9
In addition, use of oral contraceptives in healthy
ovulating women does not affect the development of
ABSTRACT
JADA, Vol. 132, March 2001 319
There appears
to be no
association
between
estrogen use
and the
component signs
and symptoms
of the
temporo-
mandibular
disorder
syndrome in
a randomly
selected
community
sample.
J
A
D
A
C
O
N
T
I
N
U
I
N
G
E
D
U
C
A
T
I
O
N
✷ ✷
®
CLINICAL P R A C T I C E
J
A
D
A
C
O
N
T
I
N
U
I
N
G
E
D
U
C
A
T
I
O
N
✷ ✷
®
A
R
T
I
C
L
E
2
Copyright ©1998-2001 American Dental Association. All rights reserved.