22 LEAD GLASS–FILLED RUBIES GEMS & GEMOLOGY SPRING 2006
em corundum has been a mainstay of the
jewelry industry for centuries. The demand
for rubies and sapphires has usually outdis-
tanced supplies, and for much of history only the
very wealthy could afford them. With the discovery
of additional deposits during the 20th century, the
supply of these gems increased dramatically.
However, there continued to be more demand for
these beautiful stones than Mother Nature could
provide.
Thus enters the art of treatment. We use the term
art here because many if not most of the treatments
were not developed by scientists but rather by exper-
imenters who relied largely on luck or trial and error.
Many of those who developed these techniques
never fully understood the science or the “why” of
what they were doing, but they understood the
“what” and the “how” very well.
Corundum, as a very durable material, lends
itself to many treatments. And ruby, being the most
prized color of corundum, is often a prime focus of
these treatments. Over the years, ruby has been sub-
jected to heat treatment to change its color and/or
improve its clarity; fracture healing to improve clar-
ity and get a higher yield from naturally fractured
rough; glass filling of cavities to improve appearance
and add weight; and diffusion, dyeing, coating, and
synthetic overgrowth, among others.
The latest venture into ruby treatments involves
an improvement in clarity enhancement. In the past,
the fractures in rubies have been filled with oils,
which do little to improve apparent clarity, and
glasses, mostly silica based, which are better than
oils but, in our opinion, still not very effective
because of their relatively low refractive index.
This newest treatment is based on the same prin-
ciple that has been applied to emerald and diamond:
use of a filling material that closely matches the
refractive index of the host material to minimize the
appearance of the fractures. In the case of this new
treatment, the results are remarkable (figure 1). This
article looks at the introduction of this technique, its
identification in ruby, and its response to various
durability tests.
G
IDENTIFICATION AND DURABILITY OF
LEAD GLASS –FILLED RUBIES
Shane F. McClure, Christopher P. Smith, Wuyi Wang, and Matthew Hall
See end of article for About the Authors and Acknowledgments.
GEMS & GEMOLOGY, Vol. 42, No. 1, pp. 22–34.
© 2006 Gemological Institute of America
In early 2004, the GAAJ laboratory in Japan issued a lab alert about rubies they had seen that
had large numbers of fractures filled with high-lead-content glass, which made them appear very
transparent. Since then, large quantities of this material have reached international markets. This
dramatic treatment is not difficult to identify with a standard gemological microscope, since it
has characteristics similar to clarity-enhanced diamonds (flash effect, gas bubbles, etc.).
However, locating filled cavities in reflected light is more challenging, as the surface luster of the
filler is close to that of ruby. The filling material appears to be very effective in reducing the
appearance of fractures. Durability testing of a few samples by highly skilled jewelers indicated
that the filler was fairly resistant to heat exposure during jewelry repair procedures, but it reacted
readily with solvents.