Optimal shape and position of a thick deflector plate in front of a
hydraulic Savonius turbine
Emeel Kerikous
a, b, *
, Dominique Th
evenin
a
a
Lab. of Fluid Dynamics & Technical Flows, Univ. of Magdeburg “Otto von Guericke”, 39106, Magdeburg, Germany
b
Mechanical Power Engineering Department, Faculty of Engineering-Mattaria, Helwan University,11718, Cairo, Egypt
article info
Article history:
Received 13 May 2019
Received in revised form
12 September 2019
Accepted 17 September 2019
Available online 21 September 2019
Keywords:
Hydraulic turbine
Savonius
Blade shape
Optimization
CFD
Deflector plate
abstract
This paper describes an optimization procedure for the shape and position of a thick deflector plate in
front of a hydraulic Savonius turbine to improve the output power of the system for a constant frontal
area. Seven geometrical parameters are taken into account during the optimization process. The simu-
lation code Star-CCMþ is used to investigate the flow field around numerous structures to obtain the
optimal configuration. This code is driven by OPALþþ (in-house code optimization). During the opti-
mization procedure, maximizing the average power coefficient (C
p
) is the main objective function. The
optimal configuration improves the C
p
by almost 11% for a tip speed ratio l ¼ 1:1 in comparison with the
traditional Savonius turbine. The hydrodynamic features of the turbine with the optimal deflector plate
are discussed in detail and compared with the standard turbine, explaining that the increase in the
turbine performance was obtained by an improved pressure distribution and enhanced flow configu-
ration around the turbine blades. The performance of the turbine with optimal deflector plate is finally
compared with the standard design for the whole operation range by varying the tip speed ratio. This
comparison reveals that the power coefficient C
p
is increased by nearly 15% for l ¼ 1:2. Finally, it has
been checked that the turbine with the deflector plate is still self-starting. The obtained design should
not only be very useful to considerably improve the power of the turbine at a constant frontal area but
also effective to protect the returning blade from collisions with suspended objects thanks to the
deflector plate.
© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
The ever-growing energy demand in the world is one of the
most important problems to be solved today, coupled to a contin-
uous growth of population. Obviously, renewable energy sources
should be preferred as far as possible to fulfill this purpose.
Considering that water covers 71% of the earth surface, hydropower
appears as a particularly attractive source of green energy. Water
energy can be mainly extracted by two different techniques. The
first, currently mostly used one, relies on the potential energy of
water, using a hydraulic head difference and needing some kind of
dam [1,2]. The other approach converts directly the kinetic energy
of water to useful mechanical power, relying on hydro-kinetic
turbines [3]. Both processes can be combined in practical systems
[4]. While using a head allows employing much larger systems with
a very high efficiency, the associated dam typically leads to a major
impact on landscape, population, fauna and flora, resulting into
very complex political decisions. It is clear that there are many
advantages regarding environmental issues in case of using only
hydro-kinetic turbines; besides, they are commonly very simple
and cost-efficient. Unfortunately, their efficiency is very low,
explaining why many projects are running to improve this point in
various countries [5e8]. Prototype hydro-kinetic turbines have
been already tested by various companies such as Electric Energy
Limited (UK), Alternative Hydro solutions Limited (Canada), Lucid
Energy Technology (USA), Throptom Energy services (UK), and
Seabell Int. Co., Ltd. (Japan) [9]. However, hydrokinetic turbines
generate very restricted energy. Moreover, their power coefficient
is generally extremely low compared with the theoretical power
coefficient ð59:3%) defined by Betz limit [10].
Hydro-kinetic turbines are a recent research topic but the
literature regarding wind turbines can be surely used to obtain the
main concepts for this field. Water turbines working at water speed
* Corresponding author. Lab. of Fluid Dynamics & Technical Flows, Univ. of
Magdeburg “Otto von Guericke”, 39106, Magdeburg, Germany.
E-mail address: emeel.kerikous@ovgu.de (E. Kerikous).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Energy
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/energy
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.energy.2019.116157
0360-5442/© 2019 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Energy 189 (2019) 116157