Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Vacuum
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/vacuum
Influence of quantum intermolecular interaction on internal flows of
rarefied gases
Felix Sharipov
Departamento de Física, Universidade Federal do Paraná, Curitiba, 81531-980, Brazil
ARTICLE INFO
Keywords:
Quantum scattering
Orifice flow
Direct simulation Monte Carlo
ab initio potential
ABSTRACT
In order to model gaseous flows over the whole temperature range beginning from 1 K, the intermolecular
interaction should be considered on the basis of quantum approach. Such a consideration becomes important in
case of light gases like helium and hydrogen. Recently, the direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method widely
used to calculate flows of gases has been generalized to implement the quantum approach to intermolecular
collisions. To evaluate the influence of the quantum scattering on typical flows of light gases, a benchmark
problem has been solved for two helium isotopes
3
He and
4
He using an ab initio potential. More specifically, the
flow-rate and flow-field of helium flowing through an orifice have been calculated over the temperature range
from 1 K to 300 K for various values of the pressure ratio with the numerical error of 0.5%. As expected, no
influence of the quantum effects on the flow-rate has been detected for the temperature 300 K. Though, the
quantum approach requires less computational effort than the classical one at this temperature. For temperatures
lower than 300 K, the influence of the quantum effects exceed the numerical error and reaches 41% at the
temperature of 3 K. In this case, the quantum interaction is the only approach to model gas flows.
1. Introduction
The direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) method [1] is widely
used to calculate rarefied gas flows in vacuum systems, microsystems,
around space vehicles, etc. The open codes SPARTA [2] and FOAM [3]
based on this method became a widespread tool used in many tech-
nological fields. An essential part of this method is a simulation of in-
termolecular collisions that requires a physical potential in order to
obtain reliable results. Recently, the DSMC method has been general-
ized to an arbitrary potential [4] using the phenomenological Lennard-
Jones potential as an example. Along with phenomenological potentials
containing some adjustable parameters, the generalization of the DSMC
method allowed us to apply ab initio (AI) potentials [5], which are free
from such parameters. Nowadays, the ab initio potentials are available
in the open literature, see e.g. Refs. [6–13], practically for all noble
gases and their mixtures Thus, the DSMC method based on AI potential
[5] became free from adjustable parameters and was used to study the
influence of the interatomic potential on various phenomena in rarefied
gases [14–18]. In all these works, the intermolecular interaction was
considered basing on the classical mechanics which is well justified at
high temperatures for heavy gases. As is known [19–25], the interaction
of light gases, e.g. helium, hydrogen, at low relative velocity is not
classical any more so that the quantum effects must be considered. In
the previous paper [26], it was shown that the classical interaction
applied to transport phenomena through helium at low temperatures
leads to a significant error of heat flux and shear stress.
The aim of the present paper is to evaluate the influence of quantum
effects in a benchmark problem of vacuum gas dynamics [27]. More
specifically, we are interested in quantum effects only in interatomic
iterations. Other effects, like high densities at low temperatures when
the interatomic distance is comparable to the de Broglie wavelength,
are disregarded here. The benchmark problem considered here is a
rarefied gas flow through a thin orifice [28], which is solved for both
quantum and classical approaches to intermolecular collisions. It is
pointed out the temperature range where the classical approach fails
and the quantum theory becomes an unique alternative to calculate gas
flows. This is important in many technologies such as cryogenic pumps
[29,30], cryogenic systems used in the huge fusion reactor ITER
[31,32], monochromatic beams of helium [33,34], acoustic thermo-
metry at a low temperature [35,36], experimental set-up to measure the
neutrino mass [37,38], etc. A comparison of computational effort of
both approaches shows that the quantum scattering requires less
computational time in comparison with the classical approach at high
temperatures. Thus, it is suggested to apply the quantum scattering for
the whole range of the temperature.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.vacuum.2018.07.022
Received 28 May 2018; Received in revised form 27 June 2018; Accepted 15 July 2018
E-mail address: sharipov@fisica.ufpr.br.
URL: http://fisica.ufpr.br/sharipov.
Vacuum 156 (2018) 146–153
Available online 18 July 2018
0042-207X/ © 2018 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
T