PHYSICAL REVIEW E 86, 066313 (2012)
Faraday instability at foam-water interface
A. Bronfort
*
and H. Caps
GRASP, Physics Department B5, University of Li` ege, B-4000 Li` ege, Belgium
(Received 17 August 2012; published 14 December 2012)
A nearly two-dimensional foam is generated inside a Hele-shaw cell and left at rest on its liquid bath. The
system is then vertically shaken and, above a well-defined acceleration threshold, surface waves appear at the
foam-liquid interface. Those waves are shown to be subharmonic. The acceleration threshold is studied and
compared to the common liquid-gas case, emphasizing the energy dissipation inside the foam. An empirical
model is proposed for this energy loss, accounting for the foam characteristics such as the bubble size but also
the excitation parameter, namely the linear velocity.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.86.066313 PACS number(s): 47.20.−k, 47.57.Bc, 47.35.−i
I. INTRODUCTION
Aqueous foams can be seen as dispersions of gas bubbles
inside a surrounding fluid composed of water and surfactant.
The rheology of those complex fluids depends on their liquid
content ϕ [1]. When the amount of liquid, with respect to
that of gas, is large (typically ϕ 10%) the foam is identified
as wet. Adjacent bubbles are free to move relatively to each
other but some energy is dissipated due to the viscosity of the
motion of the interstitial fluid [2]. In the case of dry foams
(ϕ 10%) the bubble interaction is more elastic and energy is
dissipated by the geometrical reorganization of the liquid films
separating the bubbles [2,3]. Up to now, a lot of experimental
[4,5] and theoretical [6,7] studies have been conducted on
the rheology of aqueous foams, both in two-dimensional and
three-dimensional configurations. Most of those works focus
on the bulk properties of the foam, under external constraints.
To our knowledge, the interface between the foam and its liquid
bath did not receive such attention. However, the interface
between two fluids is defined in terms of an interfacial tension,
and depends on the viscosity, the density, and the chemistry of
both fluids. In the present case, the foam and its liquid bath can
be seen as two nonmiscible fluids, with some kind of mixing
length defined by the height the water that can imbibe the foam
thanks to capillary rise.
In order to probe the mechanical properties of an interface,
hydrodynamic instabilities appear as useful tools. One of those
instabilities is the Faraday instability [8], emerging when a free
surface experiences vertical oscillations above acceleration
c
. For acceleration values in the vicinity of
c
, the free
surface is covered by a set of standing waves which can be
ordered into different geometries [8–13]. The Faraday waves
are parametrically excited and oscillate at half the forcing
frequency [8,19]. The dispersion relationship in the inviscid
and spatially infinite free fluid surface hypothesis reads
ω
m
(k) =
g
0
k +
σ
ρ
k
3
tanh(kh)
1/2
, (1)
where the ω
m
(k) are the natural frequency of each of the
eigenmode k of the surface, σ is the fluid surface tension,
ρ its density, g
0
is Earth’s gravitational acceleration, and h is
the depth of the liquid pool [22].
*
abronfort@ulg.ac.be
The threshold for instability is observed to depend on the
fluid viscosity [14,15] as well as on capillary effects [16–18]. In
case of miscible fluids, an instability can also be observed [20]
but experiments are limited by the mixing.
In the present paper, we propose to study the stability of
a foam-liquid interface under vertical oscillations. Control
parameters such as the bubble diameter D, the amplitude
A, and the frequency f of oscillations will be investigated.
After a description of the experimental setup, we focus on the
critical acceleration
c
. Attention is then put on the damping
of the waves due to the foam. A phenomenological model is
eventually proposed and validated.
II. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP
All the experiments presented below have been carried
out inside Hele-Shaw (HS) cells made out of polycarbonate
plates (130 × 100 × 3 mm
3
). Half of the cells were filled with
an aqueous surfactant solution composed of 94% bi-distilled
water, 1% commercial dishwashing soap, and 5% glycerol.
Using milli-fluidic T junctions [21], bubbles are blown into this
liquid pool and compose the foam. The cell does not have a top
wall so the foam is left in contact with air for all the following
experiments. The bubble diameter D ranges in [1; 4] mm. The
amount of foam inside the HS cell is defined as the height H
reached by the bubbles above the liquid surface. The depth of
the liquid pool is assumed as infinite. The cell is then vertically
fixed onto an electromagnetic shaker (as shown in Fig. 1)
providing oscillations which are defined by their frequency
f ∈ [5; 50] Hz and their amplitude A. The latter is deduced
from the measurement of the acceleration ≡ A(2πf )
2
∈
[0.5; 3]g
0
. The frequency ranges in [18; 28] Hz for experiments
with foam. The lower limit is due to our shaker acceleration
range and the upper one is set by the features of Faraday
waves. Indeed at high frequencies the wavelength is typically
of the order of the bubble diameter or smaller. The HS cells
are backlighted and images of the foam are recorded using a
high-speed video camera configured at 1000 frames per second
(fps).
Before each experiment the freshly generated foam was
left at rest for a few minutes in order to reach its gravitational
equilibrium. The regular replacement of the foam was so that
the foam neither ages nor evolves over the experiment duration
time.
066313-1 1539-3755/2012/86(6)/066313(5) ©2012 American Physical Society