Identification of simple mass balance
models for plant growth - Towards food
production on manned space missions
Heather Maclean
*
Denis Dochain
*,⋆
Geoff Waters
**
Mike Dixon
**
Laury Chaerle
***
Dominique Van Der Straeten
***
*
CESAME, Universit´e catholique de Louvain, 4-6 avenue G. Lemaˆıtre
1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium
**
Controlled Environment Systems Research Facility, School of
Environmental Sciences, University of Guelph, 50 Stone Road East,
Guelph, Ontario, N1G 2W1, Canada
***
Unit Plant Hormone Signaling and Bio-Imaging, Department of
Physiology, Ghent University, Ledeganckstraat 35, 9000 Gent, Belgium
Abstract: This paper presents a simple mass balance model for plant growth. This work is a
first step in the development of a model intended to enable the prediction and control of a plant
production chamber for MELiSSA, a regenerative life support system project developed by the
ESA. Photosynthesis and respiration were selected as key reactions for biomass production.
Considering these reactions, the model was developed using a mass balance approach. Reaction
kinetics were chosen based on plant physiology and standard biochemical reaction knowledge.
The identification and validation of yield and kinetic parameters were performed using data from
lettuce and beet experiments in a closed plant chamber. The model adequately predicts lettuce
growth, and predicts beet biomass and carbon dioxide flux well after an initial acclimation
phase. The oxygen prediction could be improved and should be the subject of further study.
Keywords: Plant growth modelling, identification
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 State of the Art
Plant growth models have been developed for the pur-
pose of increasing our knowledge of plants, improving
agricultural practices, as a tool in landscaping, and for
the purpose of optimization and control. Modelling ef-
forts have taken several different approaches depending
on the intended use of the model. Many plant growth
models are empirical, and apply fitted functions without
considering the biological mechanisms underlying plant
growth. These models have the benefit of simplicity, but
are not mechanistic and therefore cannot be applied to a
variety of species or over a wide range of conditions [1].
In contrast, complex metabolic models give a more com-
plete description of reactions taking place within the cells,
and are useful tools for studying plant development [2][3].
However, because of the large complexity, these models are
typically over-parameterized and unidentifiable, making
them unsuitable for prediction and control purposes.
Process based models and functional-structural models
attempt to bridge this gap. These models consider at
least some plant processes and interactions between the
plant and the environment. Process based models typically
⋆
Honorary Research Director FNRS, Belgium. e-mail : de-
nis.dochain@uclouvain.be, fax : +3210472180
refer to those models that do not take plant morphol-
ogy into account [4][5], while functional structural models
generally include an empirical view of plant architecture
[6][7]. These models work well under certain environmental
conditions, but they are usually developed for plant growth
under field conditions, and therefore neglect the effect
of some important environmental variables (for example
carbon dioxide and oxygen concentration). More mecha-
nistic models, based on the reaction kinetics of the most
important processes, should be applicable over a wider
range of condtions.
1.2 The MELiSSA Project
The MELiSSA (Micro-Ecological Life Support System Al-
ternative) project aims to develop technology for a future
regenerative life support system for long term manned
space missions. Developed by the European Space Agency,
the concept is to use microorganisms and plants to re-
generate the atmosphere, recycle water, and to produce
food for the crew on such missions. An important part
of the MELiSSA loop is the growth of higher plants in a
controlled greenhouse environment for the production of
food and oxygen from ’waste’ carbon dioxide. A model of
plant growth is required for the prediction and eventual
control of this compartment. The model must be appli-
cable at normal operating conditions, as well as during
failure and stress conditions. The main control objective
will be to provide a certain desired ’flow’ of biomass from
11th International Symposium on
Computer Applications in Biotechnology
Leuven, Belgium, July 7-9, 2010
978-3-902661-70-8/10/$20.00 © 2010 IFAC
335 10.3182/20100707-3-BE-2012.0028